#63 and #62 are tied by averages but the next song has two tens, while this song only one.
Average: 6.929
Highest: 10 (Great Username)
Lowest: 3 (alkralkra)
"Red Red Red" starts with a hauntingly beautiful instrumental but ends up being a boring filler. Her emotion-filled voice cannot save the clumsy, awkward songwriting. Quite easily my least favorite song on the album.
The production on the Jon Brion version is much more complex and rawer than the album version, and kind of overshadows the vocals. Brion's approach works a lot better on this song, and it feels more emotionally convincing for me. I still don't like it enough, though.