[Starkboy]

Rihanna because she didn't come out peaking like the others. She continue to rise, not peaked yet.

[EightSin]

It's weird, I'd say that the trinity all have their iconic moments in their careers, and yet Rihanna doesn't but she's probably been the most consistent of them all.

[Phoenix83]

Probably Andy Murray.

Oh sorry, wrong thread...

[Pretty. Odd.]

Well that was easy

[MiguelPortugal]

Rihanna.

[JeremyALD]

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

In what sis, singles? I M P A C T. I guess you wouldn't know what that is since you have Kelly in your avi.

The most successful idol of all time who helped designate siniging competitions into a cultural phenomena, rightttt.

[Giselle]

Originally posted by tcweh

Britney. There's no real trinity because Gaga isn't in Brit and Bey's generation.



But Britney has no talent. And Beyonce has never had Skyrocketed Success...So how are they eligible for being in the "Trinity"?

I was talking about Gaga, and yes Britney does.

[Qwerty]

Rihanna. Why isn't this public?

[the floacist]

Originally posted by SaneBeyhannaStan

I'll say this Rihanna has a impact in that her songs have slowly shaped radio over the last few years. she is also the biggest Island Artist to have huge success since... Hell Bob Marley. Everywhere you go people know about the short black bob, and an umbrella, hell even Red hair, and her euro influenced dancepop songs. Lastly, Whether it is looked at authentic or faux everyone knows her for her Rockstar behavior no matter how bad ass, immature, or displeasing it may be. When its all said and done, she will be remembered for her strong collection of hit songs and to an extent the GGGB, and Loud eras.

Just because Rihanna is FROM the islands doesn't make her an "island artist".

[.aR]

The one who's not included in the trinity

[RomanNavy]

Rih sold more than Gaga Beyonce and Britney tho sissies
The fact she is the youngest and accomplished the most....

But Rihanna had the most impact.
Nobody playing gaga bey brit records in the clubs.

[RomanNavy]

Originally posted by .aR

The one who's not included in the trinity

Beyonce.
Her influence is in the Soulja Boy range.

[T.C]

Originally posted by .aR

The one who's not included in the trinity

Honey, there ain't no trinity outside of ATRL so Rihanna will remain un bothered.

[Desert Rain]

Originally posted by RomanNavy

Beyonce.
Her influence is in the Soulja Boy range.

I'm praying for you sis.
Your drags are weak.
Rih's impact on music should be credited to Def Jams producers not the girl herself.
Choosing your songs over and recording over the submitted demos don't make you influential.
Wouldn't be surprised if Soulja Boy did more writing on his album than Rihanna.

[Vlad Spears]

Originally posted by Stonem

Tier 1: Gaga, Beyonce, and Britney
Tier 2: Katy, Rihanna, and Ke$ha.

Always been like that.

You could throw Nicki in the Tier 2. The stan in me really wants to put Rihanna in Tier 1, but she's not there yet. So yeah, Rihanna.

[Ignacio]

"+ Rihanna"

I DIED.

[Rihannito]

Umbrella's impact ALONE >>>> Beyonce's and gaga's impact.

Queen britney STILL the one with most impact, and she will never fade like EVER!!

And Rihanna for sure has been and still the most successful POP artist since 2005, she is UNSTOPPABLE ( she just scored her 12 th number one single, Number one album, Stadium tour already sold out, succesful movie roles,her latest perfume is the biggest selling perfum in the Uk last year and top 3 best selling WW, Second highest paid female musician this year only BEHIND BRITNEY, Times's most influencial popstar of the year, Youngest black artist to cover vogue twice, i mean if this girl is not really having any impact she wouldnt have achieved all of this things in such a short time span) and she is already breaking madonna's records when she is just 24! Madonna scored her 12 th number one at the age of 41..this says it all about RIhanna's impact and success as an artist.

And a certain stanbase on here is so damn pressed cz she took their fave's place....

[Rihannito]

Let Me add That Beyonce had Mathew and DC to back her debut up, and she was already a household name, when Rihanna came as an unknown gerl, and still managed to be successful, even when the hives were all backlashing her for being a fake copy of bey. Rihanna, gaga and britney all began from 0 an built up their careers for their own.

[Alberto]

Originally posted by lpd446

What makes gaga so special to be in the top tier?

To have sold 64 million singles and 23 million albums in 4 years of career. That's more than Rihanna in her 7 seven year "reign".

[Alberto]

Originally posted by RomanNavy

Beyonce and lady gaga had no impact whatsoever. They're LUCKY to be mentioned in the same sentence as Rihanna.

kiiii