The winner of the second generation 2 catch game is......
Oops the pokemon failed to be caught in both groups and were scared away....for now.
Group 1 - Fire starter line.
Rock throwers +10
Typhlosion +5
Cyndaquil +3
Quilava +1
Group 2 - Grass starter line.
Rock throwers + 10
Meganium + 6
Bayleef +2
Chikorita + 1
As some people pointed out having all the starters of each type in 1 group might have caused an unfair result in favour of the rock throwers, so the pokemon with the most catches from each group (Meganium and Typhlosion will appear again in other catch game rounds)