[Rainsford]

Really?

[Rated]

Grammy Nominated
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Universal Acclaim
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Debut in Top 10 for three lead singles
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Dangerous Woman
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by JonginBey

The criteria and standards for being a star today

Right.

Billboard should have done album sales, most top 10 songs, Grammy nominations, and then maybe overall social media stats.

[alfonso12]

Those achievements. the should've compared their streaming power, amount of top 10 hits, tour receipts, etc.

[KORDEI]

SNL HOST
sdkvjnlms;dvksd

They really could have come up with better measurements. It's very known that Ari murks those 2 girls.

[Lady Claire]

The random criteria

Gives the impression that was made to shade Demi or something

[SelenaTheWinner]

Originally posted by JonginBey

The criteria and standards for being a star today

Yeah, I would've loved if they included like... album sales, singles sales, social media following, spotify/vevo streaming, magazine covers, box office success, touring receipts, TV show ratings, producing TV show for different networks, endorsements [Pantene Adidas Apple Louis Vuitton Coca Cola...]
That would be cool, but SNL host is also cool.

[NEZ]

Originally posted by Stepfon

Right.

Billboard should have done album sales, most top 10 songs, Grammy nominations, and then maybe overall social media stats.

wouldnt ariana still win??

[Outlaws]

Ariana/Demi > Selena.

[Dylobs]

Originally posted by Rated

Grammy Nominated
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Universal Acclaim
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Debut in Top 10 for three lead singles
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

Dangerous Woman
✓ Ariana
✘ Demi
✘ Selena

[SebaMonster]

Originally posted by halcyonday

TALENT
✓ Demi
✓ Ariana
✘ Selena

They should've added this tbh.

Anyways, Ariana won.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by NEZ

wouldnt ariana still win??

Yes, probably. But, those are better measurements to go from then Instagram followers and being a SNL host.

[NEZ]

Originally posted by Qudron

Can we replace Demi with Taylor? She doesn't fit in and is honestly more of a twitter personality than a millennial pop star. But BB speaking the truth

taylor plays in the major league with the woman of pop, like katy, rihanna and beyonce.

ariana, selena, miley and demi are little girls to me and are all too busy trying to be like rihanna.

[Disha]

Originally posted by qurl

FAT
✓ Demi
× Selena
× Ariana

CHAHHHHH

[Grumpy Gills]

Child stardom and instagram being categorizes

[allisxn]

lmao

[SebaMonster]

Originally posted by NEZ

taylor plays in the major league with the woman of pop, like katy, rihanna and beyonce.

ariana, selena, miley and demi are little girls to me and are all too busy trying to be like rihanna.

Ariana has her own style and has one of the most unique voices in music. She isn't trying to be anyone else.

[PrinceSpears]

In terms of consistent success it's Selena > Ariana > Demi but Ariana has had the biggest peak and Demi used to have bigger first weeks than Selena

[Aaron]

They should've used album sales, Selena would've easily won considering she actually has a platinum album and an album at 800k while neither Ariana nor Demi have ever gone platinum and it doesn't seem likely (DEMI didn't do it with four hits, Ariana didn't do it with five smashes).

[Miracle Whip]

Whew

The way achievements have changed from record sales too instagram success.

These girls truly wouldn't have stood a chance before social media went mainstream.