Quote:
Originally posted by MaRy
mariah has the best voice on paper, she often faltered live, she could not sustain for a whole song... whitney and adele were/are never missing a note...
|
She could not sustain for a whole song? What kind of lie? Yes, she's struggled later into her career, but the first decade of her career were full of flawless performances.
2. Whitney and Mariah songs are objectively far more difficult to perform than Adele's. Adele has a limited range and is notable for her tone and emotive abilities. She also has decent power in her belting, but again, her belting range is very limited. Mariah and Whitney songs had far more dynamics from a vocal standpoint. They could KILL Adele songs, but Adele could NEVER with theirs.
3. This is premature. Adele may be comparable in terms of success, fanfare, and type of hype, However, she doesn't compare as a vocalist at all. And continuing to compare her to them does her and her talent no service.
4. Mariah is a better songwriter than Adele IMO.
Adele I think has the bigger peak, if not she will get there. 
In that sense yes. I do believe if Mariah & Whitney had started in this age, music would be significantly different.
