[Trent W]

Originally posted by Atlas

im sorry but this is all kinds of wrong. If you want to go by star power in 2003 than Bey wouldve been bigger in 2011 and 2012. And Britney didnt do anything in 05 and 06 and Bday was waaaaay more successful than blackout in 07

You are just benefiting Bey with those stats dates, why are you comparing Bday to late 2007 Blackout if the Bday era started in 2006? Britney released a Greatest Hits album in late 2004/early 2005 and sold close to 6 million WW, which was around the same units Bday moved those years.

[UnusualBoy]

Anyway Britney was only bigger till 2003, then onwards Bey has been outdoing her only in 2008-2009 they were almost equally again, Bey sold more albums and had hits while Britney had hits and the bigger tour.

[Eternium]

1997: Bey
1998: Britney
1999: Britney
2000: Britney
2001: Britney
2002: Britney
2003: Britney (Payola does not get counted, imo)
2004: Britney
2005: Britney
2006: Beyonce
2007: Britney
2008: Britney
2009: Beyonce
2010: Beyonce
2011: Britney
2012: Beyonce
2013: Beyonce
2014: Beyonce
2015: Britney (until Bey releases)

Originally posted by Shinning

4 doubled Femme Fatales' sales. And Beyoncé released nothing in 2012 and was still a more prevalent star than Britney (I believe she did the X Factor in 2012, which did nothing for her).

So if we're going by star power, Britney gets every year till 2010 when she fell out of the year-end most searched list, right?

[Dessy Fenix]

I'm going by an overall guess here.

1998 - Britney
1999- Britney
2000- Britney
2001- Britney
2002- Britney
2003 - Beyoncé
2004 - Tie
2005 - Beyoncé
2006 - Beyoncé
2007 - Beyoncé
2008 - Beyoncé
2009 - Beyoncé
2010 - Beyoncé
2011 - Beyoncé (4 outsold FF... Who's the real "flop" here?)
2012 - Beyoncé
2013 - Beyoncé
2014 - Beyoncé
2015 - Beyoncé

I said this in a previous thread, this isn't the early 00s anymore. Beyoncé became a bigger star since 2006-2007.

[Trent W]

Originally posted by dessy

I'm going by an overall guess here.


I said this in a previous thread, this isn't the early 00s anymore. Beyoncé became a bigger star since 2013.

Fixed

[Dessy Fenix]

Originally posted by Trent W

Fixed

B'day Deluxe enhanced her worldwide presence
I am... Sasha Fierce bought her two classics and one of the most iconic video of all time.

Step into the real world.

[Kisuke]

Beyonce > every year since she went solo and it will stay that way.

[superben]

Originally posted by Instinct

1998 - Britney
1999 - Britney
2000 - Britney
2001 - Britney
2002 - Britney
2003 - Britney
2004 - Britney
2005 - Beyonce
2006 - Beyonce
2007 - Beyonce
2008 - Tie
2009 - Tie
2010 - Britney
2011 - Britney
2012 - Britney
2013 - Beyonce
2014 - Beyonce

Britney - 10
Beyonce - 5
Tie - 2

Britney wins.

Agree.

[MrLovett]

Originally posted by Trent W

4 only really sold more albums in the US than FF, outside the US they sold about the same.

UK
4: 622,000
FF: 105,000

[Trent W]

Originally posted by dessy

B'day Deluxe enhanced her worldwide presence
I am... Sasha Fierce bought her two classics and one of the most iconic video of all time.

Step into the real world.

Bday sold about the same than Britney Spears: Greatest Hits My Prerogative, while Britney was on a break and Bey was promoting everywhere Bday.

You know Britney had way more star power and was a much bigger brand than Beyonce all those years. Until 2 years ago Beyoncé really surpassed Britney cause in 2011 they were still extremely close in success.

[CandyBling]

entertaining. voted for britney.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Instinct

1998 - Britney
1999 - Britney
2000 - Britney
2001 - Britney
2002 - Britney

What kinda **** ? the army is a mess. Yall do the most not including DC in Bey her career.
So what are they comparing Britney in these years with ?

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Trent W

4 only really sold more albums in the US than FF, outside the US they sold about the same..

Did zzmyth tell you this ? Cause it most def sold more outside the US too.

[swissman]

Originally posted by Trent W

Britney was a monster compared to Beyoncé the entire last decade until the IASF were Bey clearly won.

You have to be deluded to think otherwise, I mean yeah DIL sold a bit more than ITZ and Bday sold more than Blackout, but one era lasted very few months and the other was during a mental breakdown. It's too obvious

Still, you're making an excuse when the reality remains the same.

[alimonster]

Ever since Beyonce debuted solo she was bigger than Britney

[Fans]

Lol how does 2007 belong to Beyonce

[Dessy Fenix]

Originally posted by Trent W

Bday sold about the same than Britney Spears: Greatest Hits My Prerogative, while Britney was on a break and Bey was promoting everywhere Bday.

You know Britney had way more star power and was a much bigger brand than Beyonce all those years. Until 2 years ago Beyoncé really surpassed Britney cause in 2011 they were still extremely close in success.

Your first point only aid my argument. If Britney didn't do promo that year, that's her loss.


Where's the star power in her sales? Blackout and Circus didn't outdo B'Day and Sasha Fierce.

Beyoncé was a BEAST during Sasha Fierce era and Britney couldn't outdo her at all during that era despite having hits like Womanizer.

[swissman]

Beyoncé seems to be owning 2015 too.

[alimonster]

Originally posted by Trent W

4 only really sold more albums in the US than FF, outside the US they sold about the same.

4 outside of the US sales = 1.5m
FF WW total sales = 1.9m

Gurl bye

[alimonster]

Like..

DiL > ITZ
B'Day > Blackout
IASF > Circus
4 > FF
ST >>>>>>>>> BJ

The answer is clear people.