[B'Day]

Gaga

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Cyanide

I'm tired of these Nicki stans trying it every day as if their faves last album sold even 1M WW. They will of course come back with "she's a rapper!!1" as if hip hop albums havent been selling better than pop since last year

http://www.mediatraffic.de/albums-2014.htm

Only one hip hop album in the list. Lol.

[Truffle.]

Why are people talking about The Pinkprint, off topic?

----

I wasn't coming for Gaga, you delusional stans. The OP asked a question and I answered it.

[- JED -]

Lady Gaga

[Rusty]

Lady Gaga.

[Truffle.]

Originally posted by Cyanide

TF>BTW>TFM>AP in terms of sales, so not really. Even artpop sold like 1M less than a Rih album usually does with smash hits.

TFM is an EP. Don't Monsters group TFM with TF when talking about TF's sales? Why shouldn't they here, considering it was technically part of the same era.

TF + TFM = 17M
BTW = 7M
ARTOP = 2.3(?)M
C2C = 1M

Meanwhile, every Rihanna album (sans her debut) has sold north of 3M

[DevonDreams]

Rihanna
she has been consistently selling albums

[Paola Bracho]

It's obvious that the only correct answer is the one whose sales don't drop more than 100% with every new album release.

[Hi_im_new]

Rihanna. Her sales have been consistent for the last 10 years.

While the other one declines in sales by over 50% every album.

[Eternium]

Rihanna as of now. I still think Gaga could pass her because she makes better albums but Rih has sold more albums and will most likely distance herself with future releases.

[Mariano]

Gaga.

She has sold 5M+ albums 3 years in a row, something Rihanna has never done in a single year.

And Gaga's at 28M Rih at 30M and Rih started 2005 and has released 4 more albums than Gagz

Also: last time Rihanna had a smash album - 2010

Last time Gaga had a smash album - 2011 and it sold more than Loud so yeah

So Rihanna selling 9M with GGGB and then 2M with RR is consistent (in a better sales climate) than Gaga selling 17M then 7M and then 2M in a worst selling market ?

Gaga's average is better so she wins.

[Temporal]

Gaga.

[Dessy Fenix]

Gaga. People bringing up C2C but we have to remember that it was a different direction overall.

[enxe]

Gaga

[halcyonday]

The one that sold more.

[Notorious MINAJ]

Originally posted by Cyanide

I'm tired of these Nicki stans trying it every day as if their faves last album sold even 1M WW. They will of course come back with "she's a rapper!!1" as if hip hop albums havent been selling better than pop since last year

Originally posted by FreeBitch

C2C sold more PInk Print without any global hit.

Originally posted by Starstruck.

http://www.mediatraffic.de/albums-2014.htm

Only one hip hop album in the list. Lol.

Why are yall so mad? All the good sis said was Rihanna was more consistent...


OT: Rihanna

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Truffle.

TFM is an EP. Don't Monsters group TFM with TF when talking about TF's sales? Why shouldn't they here, considering it was technically part of the same era.

TF + TFM = 17M
BTW = 7M
ARTOP = 2.3(?)M
C2C = 1M

Meanwhile, every Rihanna album (sans her debut) has sold north of 3M

you are missing the point sister.

TFM didn't sell its 17M copies in 1 year

Gaga has been smashing album sales more than Rih has EVER been.

2009 Gaga sold more than 6M albums combined.
2010 Gaga sold more than 7M albums combined
2011 Gaga sold more than 7M albums combined

3 years in a row Gaga has sold more than double of what Rihanna has ever managed to sell in a single year and then in 2013-2014 Gaga sold combined 3M+ albums with ARTPOP and C2C.

so how is that a huge decline ?

2012 - no album
2013 - 2M albums
2014 - 1M albums

So if Adele's next album sells only 5M WW, she will also be a worst album seller than Rihanna, cuz Rihanna is more consistent

[BadToYou]

Originally posted by Mariano

Gaga.

She has sold 5M+ albums 3 years in a row, something Rihanna has never done in a single year.

And Gaga's at 28M Rih at 30M and Rih started 2005 and has released 4 more albums than Gagz

Also: last time Rihanna had a smash album - 2010

Last time Gaga had a smash album - 2011 and it sold more than Loud so yeah

So Rihanna selling 9M with GGGB and then 2M with RR is consistent (in a better sales climate) than Gaga selling 17M then 7M and then 2M in a worst selling market ?

Gaga's average is better so she wins.

Rihanna hasn't sold 5m in a single year with an album? what about LOUD.

LOUD and BTW don't have much difference in sales. Both hit albums.

And Rated R sold 3.2m not 2m.

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

http://www.mediatraffic.de/albums-2014.htm

Only one hip hop album in the list. Lol.

And how many jazz albums you see ? Gaga wins.

[Homebrand]

Gaga i guess since she has sold close to Rih with less albums

I'll wait for r8 to make a final statement though!