its funny how they blame bey all over the web for the writing credits
ya'll need to get a reality check thats how the business works
1. she has nothing to do with the credit list
2. It depends on which deal you have, cause the credits just show how the money got split
some ppl get credits just because they are jamming in the studio together but they never wrote one word
some ppl have just 5% credit on a song because they added a drum, snare, vocal arrangement or just because a friend benefit. thats daily business in the music industry.
At the end of the day the most artists dont even see these splits, goes between the label ,producer, songwriter, mixer, manager etc.
just an example
writing credits
Beyoncé Knowles 10%
Rodney Jerkins 15%
Delisha Thomas 10%
Makeba 55%
Keli Nicole Price 5%
Shawn Carter 5%
She should've kept this and got a hit 
