both new songs are good. the video for if i were a boy is very well done in black a white and has a nice concept. this one is kind of different. i personally don't like it but i get that beyonce is trying to show that she can dance without stopping in a whole video. she's taking risks. lets see what happens. i hope what she does then will be better. HOPE!
i think the reason why she didn't do it in a club is because it's a club song. So OBVIOUSLY everyone thought it would be based around a club..so she stepped OUTSIDE of the box once again to prove people wrong. Oh yea who said Queen Bee can't dance.? She just danced circles around half the music industry. She had it with a plain background and things to take it back old school...to keep all the attention on her. Addin clubs and ish would take focus off her.