[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by SomeLikeIt18

ciara is a great performer but in all honesty part of the performance of a singer is suppose to include well....singing ......... so overall its not ciara

Obviously you're a huge Amerie fan and made this thread hoping for everyone to say Amerie, and then to disagree with them if they don't.

Anyways, its Ciara. She can't sing worth ****, but she can put on a show. Part of a performance is to entertain. We know the singer is a singer by listening to their albums/singles. So when they get on stage we expect something bigger than just singing.

[Queh]

none of them are vocalist. i don't think any of them are horrible singer. they're all okay at best and then ci gets the edge with her videos and performances and artistry.

ci writes produces and performs.....

[Delicious]

Ciara is the best performer, Amerie & Rihanna are better singers

[beeandririfan1]

Yeah I think vocally Rihanna is pretty good and Ciara is the awesome dancer on the stage and I'm not sure I've seen Amerie perform. I'd have to see one of her performances to know.

[2hot2handle]

CIARA

[Firestorm]

Tie between Amerie and Ciara. Rihanna would go last.

In my opinion, Ciara's performance skills rival the Britney of six years ago.

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by Firestorm

In my opinion, Ciara's performance skills rival the Britney of six years ago.

3 years.

[1-N-Only21]

^ I think when Brit first came out.

PERFORMANCE SKILLS
Ciara > Rihanna > Amerie? (Don't Remember her performing)

SINGING SKILLS
Ciara & Amerie > Rihanna

None of them are really good singers

DANCE
CIARA >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> RIHANNA >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> AMERIE

[MusicB]

Ciara.. of course

[RoRo]

Ciara is obviously the best performer/entertainer.

But I would rather hear Amerie over either anyday

[SO.UNCOOL™]

Singer:
Amerie>>>>Rihanna>>>>Ciara

Dancer:
Ciara>>>>Amerie>>>>Rihanna

Overall Performer:
Ciara>>>>Amerie>>>>Rihanna

[Afterglow]

I'd say Amerie. From what I see in those videos, she has a charisma that is un-matchable to the other two artists.

[shortstuff45220]

I defintly have to go with Ciara. I am not really that famillar with Amerie perfomrance. I know she did that one song one thing.

[~ joão.]

Ciara, duh.

[♥ Shakidrian ♥]

Originally posted by NorMal

Amerie is all that matters in this thread.

first she needs to make a name for herself no one knows her right now


overall i would go w/ Ciara ...

[Firestorm]

3 years

When she was pregnant? I don't think so.

[NorMal]

Originally posted by ♥ Shakidrian ♥

first she needs to make a name for herself no one knows her right now


overall i would go w/ Ciara ...

Amerie still ***** on half the pop/r&b vocalists in the game anyway though

[Green]

Ciara

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by Firestorm

When she was pregnant? I don't think so.

She became pregnant in January 2005, she was touring in 2004, but yeah at this time 4 years ago.

[JGibson]

Singer:
Rihanna > Amerie > Ciara

Dancer:
Ciara/Amerie > Rihanna

Overall Performer:
Rihanna > Ciara > Amerie