[Penny.]

Originally posted by phatty033

slave is SEXY without being vulgar



tho i do love both songs almost equally i think

Dirrty isnt vulgar tho
its just sexy as hell & dirrrrty

[Ezekiel]

Dirrty

[MohammadMonster]

slave is sexier & better song & better video & better choreo & better performances & fresher

/endthread

[JustThatGreat]

I literally can't decide.

[BionicMartin]

Slave feels so empty and underproduced. But Dirrty is my favourite song of all time, so I can't really pretend I'm not bias.

[hardbrit]

Slave 4 U >>>

It is iconic and everyone likes it.

OR as this puts it:
Allmusic comments: "Like her peer Christina Aguilera, Britney equates maturity with transparent sexuality and the pounding sounds of nightclubs ... Where Christina comes across like a natural-born skank, Britney is the girl next door cutting loose at college, drinking and smoking and dancing and sexing just a little too recklessly, since this is the first time she can indulge herself."

[Penny.]

Originally posted by RajibDavid

Well, Dirrty was #1 in the UK. Wouldn't call it a flop. Anyway, Dirrty wins. It was all over the TV back in the day.

well i just mean it flopped in the US which was surprising cos it was an amazing song & she had had such an incredible debut era
so for what was expected it flopped but at least the flawless UK got it right

[BarbaraPalvin]

Dirrty. Not compare it with a flop

[Trent]

Dirrty KNOCKS & the video is epic.
Slave is so overrated.

[ladygagas]

Originally posted by phatty033

slave is SEXY without being vulgar



tho i do love both songs almost equally i think

Basically this. Dirrty screams desperation but it's one of xtina's best B0PS!

and then we have Slave. Iconic song + iconic performance + iconic video AND iconic choreography

[QueenBeé]

I'm a Slave 4 U

[NUL LDR]

it's hard to decide, but I'll go with Dirrty

[Crush2.0]

DIRRTY has aged so well, it still sounds fresh.
The video gives me life everytime.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by BarbaraPalvin

Dirrty. Not compare it with a flop

well theyre comparable cos they came out about the same time & both showed them in a much more sexual light then had previously been seen

but yes Dirrty >>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Truth Teller]

'Dirrty' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> lives and careers

But 'Slave' is Britney's best lead single along with 'BOMT'. Epic song, epic video

[Unusualyou]

Originally posted by BarbaraPalvin

Dirrty. Not compare it with a flop

please Slave is not a Flop

actually was higher in the USA than Dirrty and was 4 in the UK
and 2 Worldwide higher also than Dirrty

Slave but i love Dirrty

[dirrtydiana]

Originally posted by Eternium

"I'm a Slave 4 U" is better in every aspect. I personally saw "Dirrty" as a rip-off that just went too far with the theme of the video.

I love dirrty. I mean look at my username.



But I agree. Slave >>>> in every single aspect from musical arrangement, controversy, snake performance, video, urban rhythm, choreo.

Xtina released hers like over a year later and she rarely performs it. Say a lot about the song lol.

Edit: just saw the op.

[Superpower]

I'm A Slave For You

[rawwritsmikey]

Dirrty, it's my jam.

Slave is still good too.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Crush2.0

DIRRTY has aged so well, it still sounds fresh.
The video gives me life everytime.

oh god the video is so epic & sexy & perfect