[Bey_Rihstan]

Simon is all I need.

[tell_me_a_lie]

Originally posted by Lethal

Simon Cowell, Beyonce, Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson, Randy Jackson

That would be an expensive line-up and one season is not enough to pay them.

[Abiotic]

Simon Cowell, Madonna, Harry Connick Jr., and someone else, idk.

[iforgiveyou]

Kelly Clarkson, Adam Lambert, Carrie Underwood, Clay Aiken

[Raphy23]

Simon, Katy, Keith

Or even the current panel but remove jennifer and add Katy.

[Music & Science]

Simon, Randy, Paula and Kelly Clarkson

Second option: Simon, Justin Timberlake, Kelly Clarkson and Mariah

[Kamil24]

Carly, Cher Lloyd, Ellie

[Kamil24]

Why is everyone saying Simon? He is a terrible judge!

[HausOfJustin]

Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, Randy Jackson, and maybe that Cara girl that was a judge for a few seasons.

[HausOfJustin]

Originally posted by Kamil24

Why is everyone saying Simon? He is a terrible judge!

Simon is iconic as a judge though

[MDJD11]

Keith, Madonna, Paula Abdul

[Kamil24]

Originally posted by HausOfJustin

Simon is iconic as a judge though

He is iconic for his bad comments. After auditions are done (I'm guessing none of you watch past the auditions), he sucks, knows nothing about singing, is extremely biased, etc.

[Raphy23]

Originally posted by Kamil24

He is iconic for his bad comments. After auditions are done (I'm guessing none of you watch past the auditions), he sucks, knows nothing about singing, is extremely biased, etc.

Your still bitter that he hated Soibhan. She's wasn't that good. Get over it!

[Kyle.]

Nicki Minaj
Simon Cowell
Paula Abdul
Jennifer Lopez

[Kamil24]

Originally posted by Raphy23

Your still bitter that he hated Soibhan. She's wasn't that good. Get over it!

You're*
Siobhan*
She*

I don't see what Siobhan has to do with this.

[Quiqui4eva]

The first three + Nicki tbh

[Raphy23]

Originally posted by Kamil24

You're*
Siobhan*
She*

I don't see what Siobhan has to do with this.

You know exactly what Soibham has to do with this.

[MMMinaj]

Originally posted by viperial

people w/ actual talent

Then last years panel was perfect for you. 4 very talented artists who slayed

[Raphy23]

I would definitely love Simon on the panel (wish he never did xFactor). I love Simon's brutal honesty. Is he lying though?


Just using this as an example. Like imagine if we only had Randy, Ellen, and JLo on the panel. Who would speak the truth? That's why I would like someone like Simon or even Katy Perry on the panel.

[Indigo Blue]

Khia, Stevie J, Patti LaBelle, Elton John