[prollyallmyfault]

Originally posted by bijonse

4 is a masterpiece second only to BEYONCÉ

but it is not iconic

Better word - lemme edit the title. Also, who was pressed and hit the mods with a report? Don't some folks know not to waste mods time?

[Body Talk]

4 is damn near perfect. I honestly didn't think she could top it.

It's going to be remembered as her hidden gem and truly as the album that cemented her status as a pop star and in an entirely different stratosphere than all the other girls.

[Watch'N'Learn]

Originally posted by Johnny Cash

Neither did BEYONCE...

BEYONCÉ could possibly change the whole way promo works not to mention how many people are gonna start making visual albums

[jax.]

Originally posted by Johnny Cash

Neither did BEYONCE...

Yes it did. Why are you always shading Bey with her in your sig? Get her out.

[StonedSoulPicnic]

I forgot about that album. Anyway, you're wrong. It's not iconic yet. Good album though.

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by Jax

Yes it did. Why are you always shading Bey with her in your sig? Get her out.

Maybe you didn't read my previous comments where I was basically worshiping "4" Bragging about sales is not being a good stan.

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by Watch'N'Learn

BEYONCÉ could possibly change the whole way promo works not to mention how many people are gonna start making visual albums

BEYONCE wasn't even the first album to be released by surprise. If anything its her business move that its iconic not her album.

4 is a masterpiece and just because it didn't sold much doesn't mean its bad. Just because BEYONCE is selling great doesn't mean its that great.

[MLover]

I've said this before and I'll say it again the Queens album trinity will always be B'Day, 4 & BEYONCÉ until 2050 when she decided to release another masterpiece

[MLover]

Originally posted by rayrrock

4 is damn near perfect. I honestly didn't think she could top it.

It's going to be remembered as her hidden gem and truly as the album that cemented her status as a pop star and in an entirely different stratosphere than all the other girls.

This.

[Superpower]

4 is amazing but what can you expect? This is atrl

[Jet]

It's an underrated classic

[NoxGood]

4 was a good era.. She changed her sound it wasn't like the previous albums.. She wanted us to grow with her it was definitely iconic

[Solaris]

4 is ok. I love Countdown, Schoolin Life and Love On Top.

[montrealxo]

Originally posted by keyboardhero35

i'm sorry but some of you people on this forum wouldn't no good music if it bit you in the penis. honestly, i've been on this forum for only a few days and it astounds me how if something doesn't sell as good as it should it's considered a flop. WHAT ABOUT THE MUSIC? no one ever talks about the quality of the music. 4 is an excellent, excellent R&B/Pop record, and i think it's amazing that people would dare to call something like that or even ARTPOP a flop. Why should we care what the general public decides to buy?


and for the people who don't like 4 I dare you to listen to Love on Top, Rather Die Young, End of TIme, and Countdown and tell me they're not bops.

*know

But yesssssssss. No lies spotted.

[jack516]

it is a horrible album. her new one >

[Slow Down]

I liked 4 far more than Beyonce. I wish this album would've seen that level of success. The imagery & music was just so spot on. If only they wouldn't have picked such unworthy singles in the beginning, the era could've done a lot better.

[RudeBoy93]

Only six songs are good! Maybe 8!

[T-Swizz]

Originally posted by Johnny Cash

Neither did BEYONCE...

So being the first mainstream artist to release a visual album is not important at all?

[Mr.Link]

It's not iconic but it's quite enjoyable, I can listen to it anytime, anyday.
...Until I reach Run the World.

[.KUNTana]

Schoolin' Life >>>most of 4