Poll: More iconic: Janet Jackson vs. Kylie Minogue - Page 2

dcode78

Quote:

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Kylie by far. Nothing about Janet's career is "iconic".

You must be trolling.

BLaCKPoWeR

Quote:

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Kylie by far. Nothing about Janet's career is "iconic".

Her 1993 Rolling Stone Magazine cover and 2004 Superbowl mishap are landmarks in the history of American pop culture. Stop being retarded.

Sawdust

Miss Jackson.

Subomie

Whenever Kylie & Janet are brought up things get really messy

6_INCH_HEELS

Janet.

DitaBoy12

Both.

chilluminati

Nobody really cares about Kylie outside of the UK and a few other places. And her albums have mostly been the same thing for the last few years. Janet.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Samuel

Kylie, no one in the UK at least even really knows any songs by Janet. Kylie's entire career is iconic in Europe and Australia.

And no one in the US knows Any Kylie songs. Janet's UK success trumps Kylies US success. Janet also crushes Kylie in Asia and Africa too. Europe is not be all end all.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Llewellyn

Kylie's WW fame >>>>>>>>> Janet's U.S fame.

That's the honest truth.

A mess. Outside of "Fever" Kylie has been a non factor outside of the UK and Australia. Just look at her certifications. That's the Honest truth. Y'all act like she's on Madonna or MJ's level

Mr. Wonder

Quote:

Originally posted by Llewellyn

Kylie's WW fame >>>>>>>>> Janet's U.S fame.

That's the honest truth.

Janet has actually sold more records in the US alone than Kylie has sold worldwide, and I'm not even trolling.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Lately 1814

Janet has actually sold more records in the US alone than Kylie has sold worldwide, and I'm not even trolling.

And not to mention if you take away Janets US sales and Kylies UK sales, Janet would still have the lead by a BIG margin. But you know lately, Kylie is apparently very "global" so we must be wrong

Mr. Wonder

Quote:

Originally posted by tcweh

And not to mention if you take away Janets US sales and Kylies UK sales, Janet would still have the lead by a BIG margin. But you know lately, Kylie is apparently very "global" so we must be wrong

Kylie is really only popular Down Under, the UK, and Canada. While Janet is overall more popular in North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Lately 1814

Kylie is really only popular Down Under, the UK, and Canada. While Janet is overall more popular in North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia.

You must not have caught on to my sarcasm haha.

Quote:

That's nice but the question was about who's more iconic not who sold more.

Kylie's had many more iconic moments/outfits/etcetc compared to Janet, the only one I can think of is the nip-slip.

+ Janet isn't popular in the UK at all, I had no idea who she was until I joined ATRL in 2011, that's not even a joke.

I don't know if you are delusional or just being a troll. Are we suppose to care about your lack of knowledge for Janet? or why don't i just post her UK receipts and compare them to Kylies US receipts. Kylie has NO iconic moments outside the CGYOMH film clip.

Bríseis

Quote:

Originally posted by Lately 1814

Kylie is really only popular Down Under, the UK, and Canada. While Janet is overall more popular in North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia.

Europe? I like them both, but Kylie is much bigger here than Janet. Fact.

Rolland

Kylie, for sure. She is a global star, she is still able to successfully tour around the world and get top 10 hits at mid 40s. She has been a force in EDM and is always praised for her originality and quality, she usually gets underrated because of her lack of success in the US. Janet, might be iconic and important for african-american culture but elsewhere she has always been a non-factor. CGYOOMH >>>> Janet's career (global scale).

humbz

Miss Janet is my 2nd all-time favorite singer, but in therms of international recognition: Can't Get You Out Of My Head >>> Damita's career.

Tho I feel like Janet is still a stronger name worldwide. Just a lil bit.

QueenBLadyG

Janet. Kylie wishes she had had her impact! What kind of delusional mess would even try it!?

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

She is a global star, she is still able to successfully tour around the world and get top 10 hits at mid 40s. She has been a force in EDM and is always praised for her originality and quality, she usually gets underrated because of her lack of success in the US. Janet, might be iconic and important for african-american culture but elsewhere she has always been a non-factor. CGYOOMH >>>> Janet's career (global scale).

Janet Album>>>>Kylie's career (Global scale)

The Velvet Rope>>>Kylie's career (Global Scale)

130-140 million records>>>>>68 million records (Global scale)

Janet's influence and acclaim>>>>>>Kylie's (Global Scale)

QueenBLadyG

Quote:

Originally posted by dcode78

You must be trolling.

You know anyone saying something so foolish must be.

Rolland

Quote:

Originally posted by tcweh

Janet Album>>>>Kylie's career (Global scale)

The Velvet Rope>>>Kylie's career (Global Scale)

130-140 million records>>>>>68 million records (Global scale)

Janet's influence and acclaim>>>>>>Kylie's (Global Scale)

Janet (album) has sold 7 million in the US since it was released, I would love to know where else did she sell that much, when it has such lackluster chart-peaks. Same goes for TVR and its 3 million copies sold.

Also, I would love to see a breakdown of those 140 million records WITH credible sources to back up such claims. Not happening though.

Oh, and acclaim? Well, according to Metacritic, Kylie destroys Janet. I see what I said got under your skin, but providing false, inaccurate and exaggerated information won't change the reality. Not to mention I wasn't even talking about sales. Take your delusion elsewhere please.