|
Official Rate the American Idol Thread! (Season 6)
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
I don't even need to say it: SOME of the GIRLS stabbed MOST of the GUYS in the ass....but they were the 2nd group to take the stage. (They let the boys test the waters to see how badly they drown, and then the girls hop in and learn from their examples.)
Best: Lakisha - But Jennifer Hudson is still better then her with this song. However, I really like the fact she's a mom in the middle of this competition.
Worst: Alania or Antonella - One or both of these chicks is goin home.
On a side note: I watched back the guys competition, and the skinny Chris did a TERRIBLE job on that Gavin DeGraw song. It was a great arrangement, and is one of my favorite songs of all time, but his vocal job + performance style shouldn't be compared to Justin Timberlake. That was bad. The overrated bitch is going to get through this week strictly as a piece of "pretty boy" meat. Sanjaya was far better, who I think needs an apology from the judges, even though he appears to be creepy.
Who's TRUELY winning so far: Lakisha and Blake
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 6/9/2002
Posts: 6,789
|
*bows to Melinda Doolittle*
the only person in the whole 24 I can truly say I really like. hope she wins.
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/27/2003
Posts: 10,192
|
Melinda Doolittle - I love this chick. She seems like she can be my mom, one that won't beat me to a pulp! With that being said, great performance tonight.
Jordin Sparks - She has an incredible voice and she works the camera well. This one will make it far and she's only my age. Very happy with her song choice as well.
Sabrina Sloan - Yes, she was a bit over the top but I think she definitely showcased her potential. Oh and she looks like Leona Lewis, not that I actually like Leona Lewis. Just felt like pointing that out lol.
Stephanie Edwards - Fine, Bart. FINE.
Notes:
-Death to Gina Glocksen. DEMONIC WOMAN (who smells).
-Go away, Lakisha. You're ass is already overrated (and smells).
-Antanella, we're done.
As of now, I only feel like supporting Melinda, Blake, & Jordin when they progress into the Top 12. SUBJECT TO CHANGE.
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/1/2005
Posts: 12,107
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Brian.
As of now, I only feel like supporting Melinda, Blake, & Jordin when they progress into the Top 12. SUBJECT TO CHANGE.
|
If Blake is the beatboxer, then I TOTALLY agree...those are my three favorites as well!!!
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Melinda - 9.1
LaKisha - 8.8
Jordin - 8.7
Sabrina - 8.6
Leslie - 8.3
Stephanie - 7.8
Haley - 7.4
Nicole - 7.3
Amy - 6.8
Gina - 6.5
Antonella - 6.0
Alaina - 4.5
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2006
Posts: 385
|
The only person I like on American Idol this year is Blake
no one else has really impressed me.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
The guys were so much better than last week. Chris Richardson and Blake are my favorites so far, but I'm starting to like the other Chris too
01 Chris Richardson
02 Chris Sleigh
03 Blake
04 Sundance
05 Phil
06 Nick Pedro
07 Brandon
08 AJ
09 Jared
10 Sanjaya (creepy, creepy, creepy)
I will be surprised if Sanjaya doesn't go home after that horrible performance.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
1. jared NO HE CANT GO!!!
2. phil
3. blake
4. brandon
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Chris R - 7.7
Blake - 7.5
Sundance - 7.4
Phil - 7.3
Chris S - 7.1
Brandon - 6.8
Nick - 6.6
A.J. - 6.5
Jared - 5.4
Sanjaya - 5.0
Overall
Blake - 15.3
Chris R - 15.2
Phil - 14.5
Nick - 13.1
Sundance - 12.9
Brandon - 11.8
Chris S - 11.1
A.J. - 10.0
Jared - 9.6
Sanjaya - 9.6
Should go: Jared & Sanjaya
Will go: Nick & Brandon
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/14/2005
Posts: 1,551
|
My predictions for the Top 12
GIRLS:
LaKisha Jones
Melinda Doolittle
Jordin Sparks
Antonella Barba (She will make it through with her looks)
Stephanie Edwards
Sabrina Sloan
GUYS:
Blake Lewis
Chris Richardson
Phil Stacey
Chris Sligh
Brandon Rogers
Sundance Head (I DON'T LIKE HIM)
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
The girls were hella boring tonight..
1) Melinda
2) Stephanie
3) Sabrina
4) Lakisha
5) Alaina --> Not as bad as they said
6) Gina
7) Jordin
8) Leslie
9) Antonella
10) Haley
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
10 Still Crappy Womens
Stephanie Edwards (7/10) OK, most of my problem is that the music is too damn fast. Beyonce's solo take is a lot slower done, even with the sped up lyrics section for part of verse 1. Since she appeared to be rushing the song, I'd be tempted to score this lower. But she sold it a lot better than LaKisha. The key change was horrid, though.
LaKisha Jones (6/10) Much more controlled performance this week. Not quite understanding why you wore a shorter denim skirt. Not oversung as much (like on AIATYING) and much more enjoyable. Upgrade!
Jordin Sparks (2/10) Lord, why does everyone have to do "Reflections?" She regressed back to a Star Search pageant performance and I'm slightly disappointed. Maybe it's her decision to do the song.
Melinda Doolittle (2/10) This started very very VERY rough and never quite recovered. I mean, she's bound to sound better than Connie/2Cats but still. Not sure if I like it or who the perf seemed as fake as I think it was.
Leslie Hunt (1/10) Original song choice. But your vocals do not work on Nina Simone. And the more controlled and less flappy performance was just as scary as last week. And never try to scat ever again.
Haley Scarnato (0/10) You are too damn white to sell "Queen Of The Night." Nor do you have a pair swinging between your legs. of course, neither did Whitney but she acted it to sell the song. You have to be badass to sell it and she made it a stompy pageant song. Ugh.
Gina Glocksen (0/10) Ouch. And ouch. and yikes, no more satin for you young lady. And next time, try sticking to one key. And the background singer gets a -10 for her offkey shouting.
Sabrina Sloan (0/10) Still do not like her voice. And why dedicate this song/perf to Grammy? And why are we listening to The Bodyguard soundtrack. Sounded offkey in the chorus and on the key change. This just bugged like no other. Damn Chosen One.
Antonella Barba (-3/10) Jesus, fatttie sucker! You were somehow flatter this week than last! And I still expect 19E to pull the strings and make sure you go home due to "votes."
Alania Alexander (-6/10) Congrats, we have a negative! Mostly because you have no damn business singing this song. And you dedicated it to your mom? Off key and annoying like last week. Please go home.
Should be forcebly removed - Alania and Antonella
Shall be sent far far away - Antonella (cuz the "voters" didn't "vote) and Leslie.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
The girls were better than the guys again, imo.
01 Melinda
02 Jordin
03 Stephanie
04 Lakisha
05 Gina
06 Sabrina
07 Antonella
08 Leslie
09 Alaina
10 Haley
Alaina should've been gone since last week and Haley did a horrible performance, maybe I just don't like her.
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
My top 5 this week:
1. Blake
2. Melinda
3. Jordin
4. Chris R
5. Sabrina
On Deck:
Stephanie
Chris S
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 6,045
|
So I've concluded that this season sucks balls. I tried my best to grab some attention to some of these contestants, but aghhh!!! What the hell? I'd rather hear Mikalah from Season 4 sing! None of the girls this season are nearly as good (or entertaining I should say) as Kat, Kellie, Kelly C., Carrie, or even Dianna!
There is one exception though. I thought Leslie's performance was horrid last night, but she's still cute. LOL. I got through every single time though when I voted for her. I stopped around 10 o'clock. So yeah, she might be going home, but I hope not!
If it were up to me, I'd boot Alaina and Antonella. Especially Antonella.
As for the guys, Chris R. and Blake get my votes.... Anybody that can pull off a Jason Mraz song is A-okay in my book.
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 6,045
|
Quote:
Originally posted by dancing aLone
So I've concluded that this season sucks balls. I tried my best to grab some attention to some of these contestants, but aghhh!!! What the hell? I'd rather hear Mikalah from Season 4 sing! None of the girls this season are nearly as good (or entertaining I should say) as Kat, Kellie, Kelly C., Carrie, or even Dianna!
There is one exception though. I thought Leslie's performance was horrid last night, but she's still cute. LOL. I got through every single time though when I voted for her. I stopped around 10 o'clock. So yeah, she might be going home, but I hope not!
If it were up to me, I'd boot Alaina and Antonella. Especially Antonella.
As for the guys, Chris R. and Blake get my votes.... Anybody that can pull off a Jason Mraz song is A-okay in my book.
|
Oh yeah... My top 12 prediction is...
Guys:
Chris Richardson
Blake Lewis
Chris Sligh
Phil Stacy
Nick Pedro
AJ Tibaldo
Girls:
Melinda Doolittle
Lakisha Jones
Gina Glocksen
Jordin Sparks
Sabrina Sloan
Leslie Hunt (Hopefully!!!!!!!)
If Jordin and/or Leslie won't get through, I'm done with the girls. lol. Then again, I said last year that I want to pick a guy favorite this year. My faves are Chris R. and Blake.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Melinda - 9/10, Wow, she was great last night.
02. LaKisha - 8/10, It's gonna be battle of the Divas between her and Melinda. She fell back this week.
03. Gina - 7/10
04. Sabrina - 7/10
05. Stephanie - 7/10
06. Jordin - 7/10
07. Haley - 5/10
08. Alaina - 3/10
09. Leslie - 3/10
10. Antonella - 2/10, This **** has no voice on her.
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Melinda - 8.5
Jordin - 8.3
Leslie - 8.2
Stephanie - 8.0
LaKisha - 7.0
Antonella - 6.5
Gina - 6.0
Sabrina - 5.5
Haley - 4.3
Alaina - 3.0
Overall
Melinda - 17.6
Jordin - 17.0
Leslie - 16.5
LaKisha - 15.8
Stephanie - 15.8
Sabrina - 14.1
Gina - 12.5
Antonella - 12.5
Haley - 11.7
Alaina - 7.5
Should go: Haley & Alaina
Will go: Gina & Alaina
|
|
|
Banned
Member Since: 3/1/2007
Posts: 2,747
|
American Idol, I love this show. Carrie Underwood! I am into this season, and I haven't missed an episode yet.
Melinda - 7
Jordin - 7.4
Leslie - 8.5 (She was the best one)
Stephanie - 7.8
LaKisha - 6.8
Antonella - 5
Gina - 7.6
Sabrina - 2 (I didn't like this at all)
Haley - 4.4
Alaina - 6
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
yay carrie fan!
Guys:
1) Blake
2) Chris R
3) Chris S
4) Jared
5) Phil
6) Brandon
--
7) Sundance
8) Sanjaya
Girls:
1) Melinda
2) Lakeshia
3) Stephanie
4) Sabrina
5) Jordin
6) Gina
--
7) Antonella
8) Haley
|
|
|
|
|