[DevonDreams]

If she had let it released on August 19th it would have had better sells and people wouldn't even question whether it was or not.

[Schhh]

Yes

[nky0411]

i mean, everyday there will be thread dedicated to gaga.
ha impact on ATRL
you just cant get her off your mine dont you?

[H-I-M]

That "it's going to outsell Judas and MTN" argument doesn't mean anything and should stop.
Thanks G-O-D her come back lead single is doing better than those two flops...

[Dr.Cake]

Originally posted by jomarr

It didn't flop but damn. Seriously only 1 Million WW? That's like 70 percent of her sales coming from the US.

It's funny because in the UK, around 120k people attended her shows, yet she only sold about the same (131k) there as of now. Something must be wrong . Is it even being played on radio in the UK?

[SylMacPer]

For someone like Ariana Grande, Demi Lovato, Selena Gomez etc. would've been a smash, but for Lady Gaga is def a flop!
It was hyped for a long time and it was promoted heavily and dont forget it's her lead single!

[jomarr]

Originally posted by cshumate

It was at 1M ww after two weeks iirc... It's gonna be platinum in the US in two weeks.

Oh thanks for clearing that up because 1 Million WW for Gaga after a month is something unacceptable.

[ToniGaga96]

No

[jxck]

It's closer to 1.5-2M, the 1M number came from Germany, Australia, US, France and UK alone.

I'm happy with its performance. It serves as a great opener for ARTPOP.

[cshumate]

Originally posted by H-I-M

That "it's going to outsell Judas and MTN" argument doesn't mean anything and should stop.
Thanks G-O-D her come back lead single is doing better than those two flops...

I agree with you, but people comparing it to those singles and saying it's not as successful are pressed. It's surpassing those easily in radio/sales and isn't going anywhere fast it seems. It seems like it's going to be relatively stable if not increasing on the charts soon.

[cshumate]

Originally posted by jxck

It's closer to 1.5-2M, the 1M number came from Germany, Australia, US, France and UK alone.

I'm happy with its performance. It serves as a great opener for ARTPOP.

Especially for how the era ended. After TEOG, she didn't really have a Gaga-sized hit again. You and I was nice, but it wasn't up to her standards from that era. MTN was obviously a flop. Gaga had become the weird pop star by this point too. Gaga having a stable top 10 single is good.

[JessicaVanessa]

Originally posted by jxck

It's closer to 1.5-2M, the 1M number came from Germany, Australia, US, France and UK alone.

I'm happy with its performance. It serves as a great opener for ARTPOP.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by GGD

not at all. It's a top 10 hit song. tbh it's even more successful than judas and TEOG

seriously now?

[Kula]

In which world #4 is a flop? Gaga has only 3 #1s , her standard isnt no #1

[EnigmaPopstar]

Its doing ok

[Queen Bea.]

No, the definition of a flop on ATRL is ridiculous, 99.9% of musicians worldwide could not dream of having a single as successful as Applause.

[nky0411]

Originally posted by SylMacPer

For someone like Ariana Grande, Demi Lovato, Selena Gomez etc. would've been a smash, but for Lady Gaga is def a flop!
It was hyped for a long time and it was promoted heavily and dont forget it's her lead single!

you mean 1 month before the release of single? compared to huping of 2 years for BTW?
gaga has not been a frontloader except for BTW era. i dont know why some of you ever think tbat applause will pull another BTW. it is definitely not happening. Applause gotta climb likePoker face and BAd romance did.

[TikiMiss]

the correct option is yes. but I see you were too chicken to include it in your poll

[Remember When]

Yes. No one wants to hear from her again.

[EnigmaPopstar]

And yes, Applause will end up doing better than TEOG