[BORNTOSLAY]

Originally posted by XtremeSteel

Son of a b*****. Give Me All Your Love ***** on ur tricky poll.

Calm down!

[DitaBoy12]

Originally posted by IWasHere

The one with the senior citizen.

What is your problem?? Why are you sooo pressed? what did Madonna did to you? every single thread you are there bashing and hating. I think is time for you to step away for the computer and learn how to be less of an A HOLE! and be a ***** and report me I dong give a ****. OH and btw that senior citizen you hate sooo much **** THE ONE ON YOU avatar SOOO GOOD! i guess that is why you are pressed.

[BORNTOSLAY]

Both, but that Madonna song is more disappointing, i was expecting more from her!

[KevinKDC]

Damn I voted before reading !!

[i spit on haters]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Damn I voted before reading !!

As did I. I'm still mad.

[J a y]

I voted for the wrong one too. You should really add "More disappointing:" into the title.

[AshleeSimpsonFan]

Give Me All Your Luvin'

That song was bad...

[James Maslow]

STOP

[jomarr]

Born This Way.
The video sucks so hard but I like the song.

Give Me All Your Luvin' was a big disappointment for Madonna tho. But the song and video was fun unlike BTW.

[Portus]

For me Born This Way was a great song and I think I like GMAYL only because is Madonna. If this song has been released by any other Pop Girl it would be basic.

[Great Username]

Well, The Fame Monster was an amazing album and Hard Candy was horrendous, so 'Born This Way' was much more disappointing.

[lancelovesgaga]

WTF....I thought this was a "Which is better" thread :facepalm:

Voted for wrong one

[Nait Phoenix]

Since Born This Way wasn't disappointing, Give Me All Your Luvin'...

[Lyzz the Monster]

GMAYL. Born This Way was a very inspirational song for a lot of people.

[NaughtyDog]

One is the anthem of this generation

the other one is a superbowl promo

[GeezusHaberdash]

BTW, because I have no real standard of what's considered "amazing" when it comes to Madonna

[D/X]

BTW. It was extremely hyped. Though I still consider it her best song, it was reaching everything. I mean the anthem of a generation?

On the other hand, GMAYL is being promoted as hell, but wasn't THAT hyped.

BTW was more disappointing because of its ****** video.

[cheap]

BTW, at least i can listen to GMAYL

[longjohn9898]

GMAYL just sounds horrible. The lyrics are trite, the production is dangerously bordering on generic, and Madonna's vocals are mediocre at best. There is no artistry; just an attempt at selling lots of singles by having a fun song with two random features that don't make any sense artistically (and are simply there to make Madonna seem more hip and "modern"). The song is extremely disappointing coming from the supposed Queen of Pop.

Born This Way was slightly disappointing. The lyrics were decent, the production was decent, and the vocals were excellent. More importantly, Gaga made a statement. Even if the song itself wasn't absolutely spectacular, it was a bold enough statement for the gay rights movement and equality at large for the song to be at least somewhat satisfying to those who didn't appreciate the sound. Gaga's whole message during that time was very sincere and unprecedented for a star of her level and it was, for me, partially satisfying for that. I have come to love the song; not as much as some of her others, but it is definitely a great song. Madonna's new song I just can't see myself liking, either for its message or its sound.

[Gossip_Boy]

Born This Way.