[Elle♥]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

This would actually work for the "young one" slot - known in the U.S., unlike Cheryl; successful in the U.S., unlike Nicole.

I approve of her sitting next to Mimi.

Mariah isn't going to be on it.
http://m.essence.com/celebrity_head....t_judge_x-.php

As for Nicki, I definitely think it would be a good move for her. Her personality would be great on the judging panel.

[PopBoi]

Originally posted by TinkerbellBritney

Mariah isn't going to be on it.
http://m.essence.com/celebrity_head....t_judge_x-.php

As for Nicki, I definitely think it would be a good move for her. Her personality would be great on the judging panel.

and of course ... this means Cheryl will have less chance

[EastCoastTM]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

This would actually work for the "young one" slot - known in the U.S., unlike Cheryl; successful in the U.S., unlike Nicole.

I approve of her sitting next to Mimi.

[@michael]

Interesting. Would've never thought Nicki for the job. She seems too famous for it

[Darren-5-08]

Such an improvement from the suggested Cheryl Cole.

[futurelove92]

If this is truu thenn BRING ON THE NICKI GIFS that will come out of thisss

[SevenFootSounds]

That'd be so cool!

[RihMark]

I dont really think that would work.

She has the package but not the vocals. It would be kidna hypocritical for her to judge vocals. Like Jennifer Lopez always commenting on being pitchy and being so damn naggy and critical.

[EastCoastTM]

Originally posted by Rîh.røx.

I dont really think that would work.

She has the package but not the vocals. It would be kidna hypocritical for her to judge vocals. Like Jennifer Lopez always commenting on being pitchy and being so damn naggy and critical.

Have you ever heard Nicki singing live?
Have you heard her sing "Save Me" live?

[TakeItOff!]

Nicki Minaj better ****ing not.

Roman Zolanski may, though.

[Vin]

Yeah, Nicki would only be useful in being a great personality for the show, but it's logical to go with someone with more experience in the business and someone who can... sing. I won't be able to take the show as seriously with Minaj judging other people's voices. Speaking of which, is Paula not doing the show anymore?

...Vin

[EastCoastTM]

[EastCoastTM]

Originally posted by Vin

Yeah, Nicki would only be useful in being a great personality for the show, but it's logical to go with someone with more experience in the business and someone who can... sing. I won't be able to take the show as seriously with Minaj judging other people's voices. Speaking of which, is Paula not doing the show anymore?

...Vin

THIS!!!... Coming from a Ke dollar sigh ha stan

[@michael]

Originally posted by Rîh.røx.

I dont really think that would work.

She has the package but not the vocals. It would be kidna hypocritical for her to judge vocals. Like Jennifer Lopez always commenting on being pitchy and being so damn naggy and critical.

Think of all the people who have judged American Idol. Simon, Randy, Paula, Kara, Ellen, Jennifer, Steven. Steven is the only one of these judges that is a singer. You don't have to be a good singer, or even a singer at all, to know if someone else sounds good. So I don't think Nicki's lack of vocals would be a problem.

[skyler]

[Ace Reject]

Plus "X-Factor" is NOT "Idol." The point of the show is to find someone that has the whole package ...

... and considering Ms. Minaj does have je ne sais quoi about her, she'll fit right in.

[Vin]

Originally posted by EastCoastTM

THIS!!!... Coming from a Ke dollar sigh ha stan

I was being polite, so ya' best slow yo' roll.



I like to keep my focus on Monsters, but I will deviate if you make it necessary.

...Vin

[Deemy]

I dont know how I feel about this. I love Nicki bt I dont think she is fit for the job. Im happy with mariah, LA Reid and Simon but the last slot needs to be another female act. Im still holding on to a Shania twain type person to judge. She was great on American Idol the week when she guest judged. I would love to see someone of her status.

[EastCoastTM]

Originally posted by Vin

I was being polite, so ya' best slow yo' roll.



I like to keep my focus on Monsters, but I will deviate if you make it necessary.

...Vin

But you're a closeted Nicki stan so its all good Vin

......EastCoast

[Vin]

Originally posted by EastCoastTM

But you're a closeted Nicki stan so its all good Vin

......EastCoast

It's a sordid matter. We won't get into it.



...Vin