Credit Card Girl instantly comes to mind. That thread came around on one of those days when I was unfortunately offline and really missed out. Dirty Talk would likely be 2nd place.
For the record, ANTi is the bigger asterisk. BTW would have debuted at #1 as the #2 album (This Is Country Music by Brad Paisley) only sold 150k and would have sold 1M copies eventually (or possibly even match its final sales count). ANTi got a Platinum certification with a million free copies.
OT: I never got to see Credit Card Girl. And that Bey thread started by Kworb is a massive kii
She is just a terrible artist. Crazy In Love was one of the worst songs of all time in my opinon. She just isn't going to make it imo. She is horrible and so is her music. Some of the black community are the only people that keep her successful because they don't know talent. Everyone else knows better.