[Idontcareaboutyou]

Unless you're Madonna you actually need to be successful commercially to be considered A-list. So no.

[Dylobs]

Solid B-list

[OnikaChrist]

Originally posted by Qwerty1234

She's A list. There's a level of interest in her music that's much higher than for example Alicia Keys (who has truly dropped from A list status).

Mess. Alicia Keys is a legend who's been in the industry for almost 20 years now. You can't compare Gaga to Alicia Keys.

[retromaury]

no

[Ryann]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

If Britney is considered A-list, then so is Gaga

. Both have nostalgia keeping them relevant

[Same Ol' Mistakes]

If Ariana and Selena were considered as B-List on ATRL, then Gaga is an A+++ list.

[TurntUp]

Of course she is A list

[PhreshIn]

No, more like C-D.

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Well if she isn't, this is embarrassing for this site, isn't it?

[Adrz]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Actually PI is selling more than MM outside of the US so Gaga > Britney still!

Girl, she is barely doing better and she isn't a veteran of 15+ years like Britney, or on her 9th album. But thank you for admitting you hold Britney to a higher standard than Gaga. OT: No

[Qwerty1234]

Originally posted by OnikaChrist

Mess. Alicia Keys is a legend who's been in the industry for almost 20 years now. You can't compare Gaga to Alicia Keys.

She had a long career but unlike Beyoncé, you wouldn't consider Alicia a success these days. Which means she's not an A list star in 2016.

[Afferty]

Nö

[castle13]

Still an A-list CELEBRITY

[J a y]

No, of course not??

[Costa]

Being successful (or not) had nothing to do with being A-list or B-list. It's about being famous and having the power to attend, perform etc at the biggest events. Gaga will forever be A-list.

[Aurora]

A-

Not currently as successful as she used to be, but still A tier. She's not Ari/Selena level.

[adi]

Who cares about being an A List celebrity when Barbra Striesand, Tony Bennett, Adele, Florence and the machine, Lorde, Sting, Stevie Wonder, Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Rihanna, Katy Perry, Michael Jackson, Elton John, Kiss, Beyonce, Motley Crue, Kesha, Madonna, etc. Admire and praise their work. I think being one of the biggest digital and touring artists of the current times is doing her no harm. I request the OP to try a tad bit harder, his desperation is showing.

[Wonderland]

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Well if she isn't, this is embarrassing for this site, isn't it?

She'll always be A-list on ATRL though

[FutureHive]

nostalgia act

[TheVoiceXtina]

C-List. Maybe B-lister on a good day