Gaga by a very long margin. Her superbowl national anthem alone is more acclaimed than anything anyone else has done, these are fact atrl will have to deal with
As a Bey stan i will say GaGa is the only pop star that can compete with her performing wise, everyone else suck. Lol@ people saying Katy, like you can't be serious.
Literally no other female, at least out of the ones ya'll are mentioning, comes close.
Her singing ability
Her dancing
Her ability to sing on key and dance her butt off at the same damn time
Her energy
Her charisma
Her stamina (extremely underrated)
All in high heels too
She's one of the main people I can think of nowadays that can give a memorable and showstopping performance without gimmicks, extreme set design, and props.
Beyonce, who I cant tell coz am an poor ass who cannot pay her rich asses concert or even have a recent rich chance to see her rich on TV and my eyes are not rich enough. But I know Lady Gaga is genius of that, Ariana is okay as she still releys on so much playback, JLo, Rihanna, Sia, are