[Mimie]

Originally posted by Wings

Crazy In Love, Irreplaceable, Naughty Girl, Baby Boy, Single Ladies, Halo, Telephone and her performance of At Last
vs
Fighter, Beautiful, Genie In A Bottle, Moves Like Jagger and Lady Marmalade.

Beyoncé is a no brainer. You all should be ashamed for how quickly you count beyoncé out.

Are you sure about Naughty Girl, Baby Boy, and At Last? I wouldn't count Moves Like Jagger since it's recent. I don't know what to say about Telephone

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by Alexz

Xtina has her Spanish hits on her side too. They give her a wider Worldwide value. Xtina was the first woman to place three Top 3 hits in the US in a long time too. And Dirrty remains a dirty stain on her catalog but positive or negative people remember it.


Beyoncé gets played on movies with Crazy And Love a lot. But other than that she plaes against Xtina. Also, her Spanish songs didn't quite impact the Hispanic comunity.

No one is talking about Spanish songs tho.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by MrBeyonceFan

No one is talking about Spanish songs tho.

The thread is asking about hits, not just in the U.S. I'm pretty sure the OP would know what we're talking about

[Remixed]

Originally posted by Alexz

Xtina has her Spanish hits on her side too. They give her a wider Worldwide value. Xtina was the first woman to place three Top 3 hits in the US in a long time too. And Dirrty remains a dirty stain on her catalog but positive or negative people remember it.


Beyoncé gets played on movies with Crazy And Love a lot. But other than that she plaes against Xtina. Also, her Spanish songs didn't quite impact the Hispanic comunity.

Yeah, Xtina's spanish hits really gives her the advantage in other countries.

[Alexz]

Originally posted by MrBeyonceFan

No one is talking about Spanish songs tho.

We're talking about catalogs, which include all their songs.

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by MiMiLamb

The thread is asking about hits, not just in the U.S. I'm pretty sure the OP would know what we're talking about

Yeah,but I don't believe Xtina Spanish songs made impact.

[Alexz]

Originally posted by MrBeyonceFan

Yeah,but I don't believe Xtina Spanish songs made impact.

But I know they did

[Ascension]

Beyonce: Crazy In Love, Baby Boy, Irreplaceable, Single Ladies, Halo

Christina: Genie In A Bottle, Beautiful, Lady Marmalade


Also, non opinion based receipts:
Billboard Hot 100: 2000's decade end chart: http://www.billboard.biz/bbbiz/chart...9/hot100-songs

Control + F + Beyonce= 5 results
Control + F + Aguilera= 0 results (also did alternate search for Marmalade and 0)

Bey. The end.

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by Alexz

But I know they did

That's nice

[D.M.F]

The 1 with classics. Bee will get there 1 day hopefully.

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by D.M.F

The 1 with classics. Bee will get there 1 day hopefully.

[King B]

Another backfiring thread to add to your catalogue of threads, I see.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by Ascension

Beyonce: Crazy In Love, Baby Boy, Irreplaceable, Single Ladies, Halo

Christina: Genie In A Bottle, Beautiful, Lady Marmalade


Also, non opinion based receipts:
Billboard Hot 100: 2000's decade end chart: http://www.billboard.biz/bbbiz/chart...9/hot100-songs

Control + F + Beyonce= 5 results
Control + F + Aguilera= 0 results (also did alternate search for Marmalade and 0)

Bey. The end.

The chart isn't showing in that link. And remember, more successful =/= more memorable.

[Passion4MyMusic]

Originally posted by D.M.F

The 1 with classics. Bee will get there 1 day hopefully.

[King B]

*Try's to remember X-tincta's classics*

[Lararen]

Xtina has - what a girl wants , genie in a bottle , beautiful

Beyonce has - Dangerously in Love, Destiny Child Hits ( aka Beyonce hits ) , single ladies, if i were a boy , halo so I'm gonna have to go with Bey.

[Ascension]

Originally posted by MiMiLamb

The chart isn't showing in that link. And remember, more successful =/= more memorable.

I just checked and it's working. And you do have a point about success not necessarily equating to memorability; however, it does factor in.

There isn't a song on that decade end list I don't remember; and I didn't even list all the songs that appeared on that list in the ones I considered generally memorable by Beyonce. It just gives a little more non-biased perspective. That is all.

[Alexz]

Originally posted by King B

*Try's to remember X-tincta's classics*

Genie In A Bottle
What A Girl Wants
I Turn To You
Come On Over Baby
Lady Marmalade
Dirrty
Beautiful

[King B]

Originally posted by Alexz

Genie In A Bottle
What A Girl Wants
I Turn To You
Come On Over Baby
Lady Marmalade
Dirrty
Beautiful

*googles*

[Rafael]

Clearly Beyoncé...

I'm loving all the explanation from the ones that voted for Xtina trying to trash Bey's catalog... it's good reading