I don't know. The question doesn't really make sense to me. Both are artists. Both lead artistic lives. Both are famous because of their art. Both are creatively, artistically, conceptually, etc. involved. Both have adopted personas at one time or another. There's no 'real' answer. Everyone is just going to vote for his or her 'favourite' whilst discrediting the other.
Gaga. I always felt like Lana puts on a voice. Like, her studio vocals don't sound natural (it's like she's imitating someone else's voice or something). I think that's why she struggles live. So yeah, definitely Gaga. Weird comparison tho.
I must add that Gaga sacrificed part of her success for her art tho, and that means she has a lot of integrity, staying true to herself, the only thing is that people are not getting what her art stands for and its seems like shoch value most of the times.
That's odd, considering you 'stan' for Gaga. In what way, does it look like she's trying hard? Pls provide concrete examples. I am not here for fan fics.
Gaga only talks about art and how artistic her music since Artpop is, Lana makes art.
Lana. Gaga is more skilled as a singer but she doesn't have the talent for creating good songs, lana does.
And are you the music police? Because Ultraviolence and the two songs we've heard so far from her new album sound like boring, forgettable messes to me.
Borrowing heavily from real artists of the past isn't really what I call an artistic person, and let me not get into Haus, they pratically do 80% of the hard work, it's a well known fact
for me Lana has the edge because she has been following the same path since the beginning,
This is the exact reason why I voted for Gaga actually. Lana has a vision and a niche and she sticks to it. She doesn't do a whole lot of branching out of her comfort zone. Nothing majorly wrong with that, and its pretty much her only flaw that I can think of. Lana is generally the stronger lyricist, but Gaga is far more 'creative'.
Gaga until she released ARTPOP. She was creative and her music was much more interesting than Lana's. I'm tempted to vote for Lana since Ultraviolence is a way better record than ARTPOP tho
They are definitely the most artistic stars commonly discussed in this forum, that's why I picked them. for me Lana has the edge because she has been following the same path since the beginning, Gaga is not that far behind but it felt like she lost her way some years ago.
That's the exact reason why Lana is not artistic... She does the same thing over and over and over again.
Borrowing heavily from real artists of the past isn't really what I call an artistic person, and let me not get into Haus, they pratically do 80% of the hard work, it's a well known fact
Lana borrows heavily as well, most commercial artists do. It's just that nobody in the real world (see: the extreme lack of attention for her new music outside of ATRL) cares enough to repeatedly point it out.