These are completely different albums, they cannot even be compared.
Not only that, but I didn't ask about B'Day vs 4 or any other album, I asked about 4.
What was really surprising about 4 was I never really loved it, I even thought I'd stop playing it in a few months, but I didn't and I'm still playing it like it was a new release.
This was me too, I never fell head over heels and I figured it would grow old eventually with so many new releases coming out, but I've still been playing it like it just came out.
after my first listen to it, I found myself skipping a lot of the tracks except for Run The World, Countdown, Party and Love on Top
but now I'm beginning to love the other tracks on the album and find myself listening to the album more and more now just as if it's been released last week or something