[SlayMe]

Katy's. it's already iconic

[Ra.]

Gaga.

[Vespertine]

Asia

[Fred Perry]

Katy hands down.

[katyperryismylife]

Gaga.

[Bang Up]

Katy's looks really tacky and middle schoolish. Gaga's on the other hand serves high fashion icon.

[Jackk]

Originally posted by Romantica

The question was "Which singer has the better cover"
"Neither" doesn't answer that question, it didn't say "which one is good/looks amazing"

In that case, Katy.

[conatus]

this is one of the few recent Gaga shoots i've actually liked.

[vanishingbee]

Gaga's cover is better but Katy's inside photo of her laughing is better than Gaga's inside photos

[TheCutest]

QUEEN ASIA SLAYS THEM BOTH

[Aurora]

Originally posted by Reinvention

Both are amazing.

Stop with this Katy & Gaga B.S. though. I'm really f-ing over it contaminating the entire site and making the site a place of argument rather than discussion.

Well said.

[Phoenixstar]

Katy looks amazing there, but it is same pose that i have seen before.
While, on the other hand, ATRL thoughts Gaga looks ugly all the time, so they can see she looks great there.

[MM3]

Gaga.

[LilKim]

Gaga

[Nux]

Katy

[jordanjm]

I like Gaga's better she looks chic and sexy at the same time. Plus Asia >>>

[Solopop]

tbh...

[Rusty]

Lady Gaga.

[ivi]

But we are comparing current, brand new magazines....

China tbh.

[Lover]

Originally posted by Sonny

Gaga of course.

Katy's hair + outfit are ugly.

Katy of course.

Gaga's hair + outfit are ugly.