[Kang.]

Originally posted by madonnas

Judging from the singles, I don't really think GGGB will be up to snuff to the others in my opinion...

GGGB is actually a really great album. I was surprised at how consistently good the songs are. I wouldn't say it's her best, but at the time it was shocking compared to the quality of her first two.

[ImpressiveInstant]

"Break the Ice" is one of my favorite Britney songs. So damn good.

I love the graphic at the beginning, by the way

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Katie

The non-singles are amazing. GGGB is a true album you can listen to from beginning to end. Trust me

I'm willing to give it a chance... I have listened before but it was long ago and I don't remember, but I thought Rated R had a few filler and I am not a huge fan of Loud or TTT... something tells me I won't be the biggest fan but I might be pleasantly surprised.

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by madonnas

I'm willing to give it a chance... I have listened before but it was long ago and I don't remember, but I thought Rated R had a few filler and I am not a huge fan of Loud or TTT... something tells me I won't be the biggest fan but I might be pleasantly surprised.

Give it a listen and vote

[Kang.]

How does the rating scale work? Like, is a 10 defined as one of the greatest songs of all time, or just one of the best songs on the album?

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by Muggwa

How does the rating scale work? Like, is a 10 defined as one of the greatest songs of all time, or just one of the best songs on the album?

You rate every song from every album out of 10 and send it in. I know it can take a while but the results and the predicitng is so fun

[Kang.]

Originally posted by KeirtyPerry

You rate every song from every album out of 10 and send it in. I know it can take a while but the results and the predicitng is so fun

Alright, but should we just use our own judgement as to which songs get which ratings, or is there a method? I'm just confused because right now I'll probably end up giving 10s to at least a quarter of these songs.

[Clump]

Let me load Spotify real quick.

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by Muggwa

Alright, but should we just use our own judgement as to which songs get which ratings, or is there a method? I'm just confused because right now I'll probably end up giving 10s to at least a quarter of these songs.

Use your own judgement & opnion, if you think your going to give tons of 10s out try and be a little harsher. But it doesn't matter if you do give lots of 10s really

[Clump]

I feel like I am going to ruin this as I gave GGGB an average of 6

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by Clump

I feel like I am going to ruin this as I gave GGGB an average of 6

That's ok other people will rate it higher I plan on promoting this thread **** load so it should all balance out, my username isn't KeirtyPerry for no reason

[YoYo]

I love this .

this will be

1-Blackout
2-Fame Monster
3-B'day
4-GGGB

[Loghen]

Sent

[Venus]

Rihanna - High: 10 (x1) Low: 4 (x2)
Bey: High: 10 (x3) Low: 6 (x1)
Lady Gaga: High 10 (x2) Low: 7 (x2)
Britney: High: 10 (x4) Low: 7 (x1)

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by YoYo

I love this .

this will be

1-Blackout
2-Fame Monster
3-B'day
4-GGGB

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Muggwa

This is good, I've actually listened to all of these albums. I'll send in a rate sometime this week.

The top 5 in my opinion should be:
1. Bad Romance
2. Umbrella
3. Irreplaceable
4. Break the Ice
5. Telephone

...But knowing ATRL, it'll be nothing close to this. I'm predicting Blackout to dominate.

It deserves to.

Originally posted by Katie

This is supposed to be their best albums rate, but you picked Blackout for Britney?

Blackout is her best. Everyone realizes this. I'd argue that nothing she'll ever do will compare to it.

And I thought we all realized Good Girl Gone Bad > everything in Barbadian Robyn's discography by now?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by YoYo

I love this .

this will be

1-Blackout
2-Fame Monster
3-B'day
4-GGGB

What would be your ideal top ten?

Mine? THIS IS TOUGH by the way.

1. Bad Romance
2. Irreplaceable
3. Umbrella
4. So Happy I Could Die
5. Get Me Bodied
6. Gimme More
7. Toy Soldier
8. Break the Ice
9. Why Should I Be Sad
10. Sell Me Candy

Man, this rate is going to be KILLER.

[KeirGrey]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

What would be your ideal top ten?

Mine? THIS IS TOUGH by the way.

1. Bad Romance
2. Irreplaceable
3. Umbrella
4. So Happy I Could Die
5. Get Me Bodied
6. Gimme More
7. Toy Soldier
8. Break the Ice
9. Why Should I Be Sad
10. Sell Me Candy

Man, this rate is going to be KILLER.

But ace how can you put Ireepleacble ahead of Umberella & The Britney singles

I'm not going to say what i want to be top 10 because their so many flawless songs but i think the top 10 will be

1) Umberella
2) Bad Romance
3) Piece of Me
4) Irrepleacble
5) Break The Ice
6) Dance In The Dark
7) Disturbia
8) A Britney non-single
9) De Ja Vu
19) Gimme more i hope

It's just so hard to predict tho or it could be completly diffrent

[genetic fail]

So this is official... We ned some jaw-dropping graphics, Ramcoro!

[Kang.]

I take back everything bad I've ever said about Blackout, that album is much better than I remember it being.

Do we rate in intervals of 1 or .5?