[ShakTinaOnce_fan]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

yes all of them did circus theme after Xtina, because Xtina did it in 2006 and they are doing it in 2009. 2009 is after 2006, so they are doing it AFTER. But it doesn't mean that they are doing it BECAUSE of Xtina. I'm sure none of them really knew that Xtina had the album out so recently.

if you are talking about rip-offs, than please remember that Stripped was just a stripped down version of M!ssundaztood.

Linda Perry produced on both albums duh. but im not goinh to argue which one is better cause you are a p!nk fan and you are biased like I am.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by ShakTinaOnce_fan

Linda Perry produced on both albums duh. but im not goign to argue which one is better cause you are a p!nk fan and you are biased like I am.

and P!nk dug Linda Perry out of the grave and Christina of course had to work with her too.

but you are right, I'm biased and your biased...but still there was no need to bring Xtina to this thread.

and Xtina is good, even thogh I'm not a huge fan, I respect her for the voice and for singing live most of the time.

[Anthony K.]

Well, Pink's album theme is not exactly a CIRCUS theme. If she herself doesn't know that, then I better not say anything.

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by ShakTinaOnce_fan

Did i say she was? but if Madonna did it in 2004 no one used it till CHristina did it back in 06/07

I don't get this. Are you trying to say that Christina wasn't influenced by Madonna, but everybody else copied Christina? That doesn't make any sense.

As for execution... I haven't seen P!nk's but I'm sure she pulled it off the best. Brit's tour makes the most sense though, because she has been in a media "circus" for the last few years.

[N@te]

Originally posted by Anthony Kerty

Well, Pink's album theme is not exactly a CIRCUS theme. If she herself doesn't know that, then I better not say anything.

P!nk wasn`t mad, she didn`t mentioned Brit, whatsoever. And she didn`t say a word about her Funhouse themed tour. When asked about competition in the moment, her exact words was
"Right now, no one is really singing while upside down". Now go and figure it out!

[xoxokely]

*LOL* so she's saying she started the circus or carnival theme?

[Rico Shameless v2]

Pink's tour is based around the theme more. Britney truly only does it when she opens with "Circus", and the 2 magic tricks LMAO. Maybe at times when the acrobats come down.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by xoxokely

*LOL* so she's saying she started the circus or carnival theme?

sorry? I'm not sure I understand what you mean.

she didn't say anything close to that.

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

yes all of them did circus theme after Xtina, because Xtina did it in 2006 and they are doing it in 2009. 2009 is after 2006, so they are doing it AFTER. But it doesn't mean that they are doing it BECAUSE of Xtina. I'm sure none of them really knew that Xtina had the album out so recently.

if you are talking about rip-offs, than please remember that Stripped was just a stripped down version of M!ssundaztood.

LOVE.

[ShakTinaOnce_fan]

Originally posted by eli's_rhythm

I don't get this. Are you trying to say that Christina wasn't influenced by Madonna, but everybody else copied Christina? That doesn't make any sense.

As for execution... I haven't seen P!nk's but I'm sure she pulled it off the best. Brit's tour makes the most sense though, because she has been in a media "circus" for the last few years.

i dont knwo if she was influenced by Madonna or not she proabaly was since she is a fan, but im saying it ddint become a trend until recently after the B2B tour.

[CarCAL22]

Lmao, like Britney or Pink have time to even ponder about that has-been (christina)....

[fpppy]

Originally posted by Alexz

The Reinvention Tour 2004

Madonna does everything first

[ShakTinaOnce_fan]

its funny how if Christina or Beyonce does something someone else has done before they copy and arent original, but Brit does it and it just a coincidence.

[MP2K]

Originally posted by kellyc2005

who CARES who was first at doing the "circus" theme.... NONE of them have a patent on it! Let them do whatever they want to do.

There you go!

[Delicious]

Tpain >>>>>>

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by ShakTinaOnce_fan

its funny how if Christina or Beyonce does something someone else has done before they copy and arent original, but Brit does it and it just a coincidence.

Who said it was a coincidence? Don't be mad. These albums were released at nearly the exact same time. Unless either one of them had a mole in each other's studio stealing the idea, then um yeah there's no way either could know who was doing what. Also when Christina & Beyonce get caught, it's like to the MAXIMUM copying. Britney doesn't and hasn't copied to the extreme they have.

[RainMan]

Madonna has done everything already.

[emmanuel_punk]

Originally posted by ShakTinaOnce_fan

its funny how if Christina or Beyonce does something someone else has done before they copy and arent original, but Brit does it and it just a coincidence.

Totally agree but you know how britney stands are

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by ShakTinaOnce_fan

i dont knwo if she was influenced by Madonna or not she proabaly was since she is a fan, but im saying it ddint become a trend until recently after the B2B tour.

That doesn't really work either. You said Madge's tour was in 2004, Christina's was in 2006/2007, so it couldn't have been influenced very much. Well... it's 2009 now. That's an even bigger difference. It just doesn't add up. It is quite possible that P!nk, Britney and T-Pain () all got the idea for doing circus/carnival-themed tours from Christina... but it's just as possible that they didn't.

You also have to wonder if Ciara will have a "fantasy ride" tour. That sounds an awful lot like "circus" and "funhouse" to me, LMAO.

[migaruler]

maybe pink is a britney fan
hahaha