[Thor]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Madonna, Janet and Beyonce.

I like P!nk and I don't hate GaGa by any means, but they don't feel like members of a "holy trinity" to me

Nnnnn sis its about this generation only.

[romonster]

Originally posted by Black Pearl

Gaga is not a good performer at all, so no

[Rihinvention]

Replace Gaga. Not sure who with, but she's definitely not in there.

[IsidoraMarí]

Originally posted by c0caine

Beyoncé, Florence and Janelle Monae take the cake IMO

.

[Doogle]

I think I agree. Gaga is an amazing performer, I'm surprised her flopping has allowed that to affect so many people's opinions like that.

[Reverie]

Yeah, pretty much

[Buddy!]

If we're talking about this generation, then yes

[Thor]

Originally posted by Rihinvention

Replace Gaga. Not sure who with, but she's definitely not in there.

Replace her with who?

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Gaga, Bey YES.
Pink, Katy, Taylor NO

[Dancehall]

Sure. They're the three best live performers.

[Lucas32]

Florence Welch is the best female performer of this generation. Followed by P!nk.
Not sure who is third

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by Doogle

I think I agree. Gaga is an amazing performer, I'm surprised her flopping has allowed that to affect so many people's opinions like that.

I don't think it's her flopping, I think it's her stiff and sloppy dancing. At least for me, it is. I would have included her in the trinity before the BTW tour but some videos I watched from it were hideous. She shouldn't have fired her choreographer.

[Skywalker]

Yes. Incredibly talented women that are willing to bare it all for their audiences, they create magic with every performance.

[Tuxedo]

You're right, but replace Beyonce with Rihanna, Gaga with Katy and Pink with Bruno Mars.

[pink.hearts]

ugh the britney stans are always trying to make her a factor when it comes to performing

[Rei]

No.

Gaga - P!nk - Madonna

[Mariano]

Originally posted by P!nkism

Anyways if we don't count Madonna of this generation then i could agree, if we did coz she is slaying than
Madonna>>Gaga

Gaga's vocals alone make her better and more enjoyable than Madonna. Let alone her dancing skills, piano skills, theatric skills .. Combined everything makes her one of the best of all time and certainly better than Madonna Madonna is more about name, being the first major woman in POP music, than about skills ..

And not people saying Katy/Britney

[jomarr]

Originally posted by pink.hearts

ugh the britney stans are always trying to make her a factor when it comes to performing

That's because she is.

[Braz]

Not Gaga, not anymore, she totally lost it since Born This Way and her performances aren't even connecting with audiences outside of her fanbase.

Bey and Pink on the other hand are true leaders of the pack and can perform mostly everything. The full package.

[jinzo]

Originally posted by Baha

replace gaga with katy.