[RatedG²]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Not in that order. In what world is The Fame Monster bigger than Teenage Dream when it has only three singles and no number ones?

The Fame Monster includes TF sales. It outsold Katy's discography. It's not only about the U.S. so yeah it's definitely bigger

[XStaticProcess]

Originally posted by Buddy!

MDNA tho

aside from the tour, what was so big about it?

The tour was big enough but it sold 2M and had a top 10 hit.

Oh and 125M earnings and 3rd most watched Super Bowl ever.

And it received positive reviews,too.

[GreasyBruce]

Originally posted by Buddy!

MDNA tho

aside from the tour, what was so big about it?

Global Top 10 single
2m album sales
300m grossing tour

[Prismy]

My Everything should be in the Bubbling Under list at least.

[Atlas]

Wtf @ ARTPOP being bigger than Pink Friday.

[KillingYourCareer]

Originally posted by LoKoPaNdA

Bad Romance sold tons and the tour grossed more than 200M, though. But yeah I am only sure about 1 and 2, the rest could be arranged in other ways

Yes but you can't compare an era with eight top 3 singles with one that has three top 5 singles also, 1989 isn't over yet, and so far it isn't as big as TD imo. It only has commercial success and two global hits and a half and not much cultural impact, I'd wait for the end of the era to judge.

[KillingYourCareer]

Originally posted by RatedG²

The Fame Monster includes TF sales. It outsold Katy's discography. It's not only about the U.S. so yeah it's definitely bigger

We're talking about the 2010s tho

[Feanor]

How I would rank them (considering album sales, track sales, streaming, touring gross):

01.) "21"
02.) "1989"
03.) "Teenage Dream"
04.) "LOUD"
05.) "Born This Way"
06.) "RED"
07.) "The Truth About Love"
08.) "PRISM"
09.) "Born To Die"
10.) "Unapologetic"
11.) "Pink Friday"
12.) "Talk That Talk"
13.) "BEYONCÉ"
14.) "Animal"
15.) "Pure Heroine"
16.) "4"
17.) "Bangerz
18.) "ARTPOP"
19.) "MDNA"
20.) "Title"

[Notorious K.E.N]

The fact that Pink Friday is bigger than BEYONCE and ARTPOP in a local stage and global stage makes this list void

Also Roman Reloaded was much bigger than ARTPOP

[Disha]

Also Our Version of Events has outsold most of these albums

[XStaticProcess]

Originally posted by Feanor

How I would rank them (considering album sales, track sales, streaming, touring gross):

01.) "21"
02.) "1989"
03.) "Teenage Dream"
04.) "LOUD"
05.) "Born This Way"
06.) "RED"
07.) "The Truth About Love"
08.) "PRISM"
09.) "Born To Die"
10.) "Unapologetic"
11.) "Pink Friday"
12.) "Talk That Talk"
13.) "BEYONCÉ"
14.) "Animal"
15.) "Pure Heroine"
16.) "4"
17.) "Bangerz
18.) "ARTPOP"
19.) "MDNA"
20.) "Title"

The MDNA Tour is bigger than anything related ARTPOP and MDNA outsold ARTPOP or sold about the same.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

We're talking about the 2010s tho

Oh.

Well hmm, I still feel like it definitely sold at least 10M WW since 2010.. TF sales were at 4M before the TFM re release no? It still makes it much bigger than TD

[romonster]

The Fame Monster is definitely in the Top 3 like in the OP. It was huge in every department (single and album sales, tour gross, acclaim, awards, etc.)

[Buddy!]

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

The MDNA Tour is bigger than anything related ARTPOP and MDNA outsold ARTPOP or sold about the same.

ARTPOP generated 2 hits, (two top 10s *dope*, and 1 top 20) And sold 2M WW. The tour wasn't as big obviously.

[BlackAura]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Not in that order. In what world is The Fame Monster bigger than Teenage Dream when it has only three singles and no number ones?

Bigger tour, sold more, won more Grammys, VMA's, EMA"s.

[Baby Boy]

Why is ARTPOP above FF?

[Cyanide]

TFM > 1989 but otherwise ok!

[°ColdFire°]

Goodbye Lullaby?

[ultraviolento]

1. 21
2. TD
3. 1989
4. TFM
5. TTAL
6. Red
7. Prism
8. Loud
9. BTW
10. PF/BTD

[Swag]

ARTPOP tho