[Tom Vercetti]

Originally posted by Fever

inb4 LAP wins

Nope. I won't allow one of her most overrated songs on her most overrated album to win. No sir.

[Reverie]

School: Paper Planes or Scientist?

[conatus]

God, I hope Paper Planes doesn't win.

[Subomie]

With Like A Prayer I see how people might think it's overrated, but this is the site that prefers Erotishit, Shittime Stories, American **** and **** on a Dancefloor to the maverick of 80sdonna so no ma'am, it is not her most overrated by a long shot.

[Reverie]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

Ok I'll come back around 9:30 to 9:45ish my time with five more punches.

Hints:

School
Sports
80s R&B groups


Ponder that and while you're doing so, be sure to buy Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse on iTunes!!

Ooooo you better PROMOTE Mariah's best album!

Originally posted by Subomie

With Like A Prayer I see how people might think it's overrated, but this is the site that prefers Erotishit, Shittime Stories, American **** and **** on a Dancefloor to the maverick of 80sdonna so no ma'am, it is not her most overrated by a long shot.

Erotica is Madonna's best album!

I'm tired of that lullaby collection being so overrated though

[conatus]

Like A Prayer is kind of overrated but still good.

The album, not the song. The song is at least an 11/10.

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Subomie

Yeah, I don't know if I could ever get into Cher's full discography though. Donna's 80s works took it out of me enough and then there's Prince who I'm not sure if I'll ever be fully up to date with.

Cher's is hard because she has a bunch of flop late 70's albums that were only ever released on Vinyl (although Stars is one of her best albums) so I had to find downloads for those.

Sometimes I like to pretend Donna just died after Bad Girls was released tbh and that the rest of her discography is an imposter (although I do lowkey stan for Crayons).

I'm getting into Diana's full discography (minus a few of the niche Supremes albums) now.

[Changes]

Well there goes my 11. Behind These Hazel Eyes still sounds good today.

[Tom Vercetti]

American Life is overrated here? Since when

[conatus]

Originally posted by That Bad Eartha

I'm getting into Diana's full discography (minus a few of the niche Supremes albums) now.

I expect full reviews on my wall ASAP!

[Reverie]

Originally posted by Tom Vercetti

American Life is overrated here? Since when

A lot of people say it's one of her best

[That Bad Eartha]

80s Madonna is beyond underrated on this flop site, but Erotica and Bedtime Stories are great. Confessions is def overrated though. And American Life is abysmal.

Like A Prayer the song is literally flawless. And the album is also amazing. It is cohesive and tells a story without being too narrative or samey.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Tom Vercetti

American Life is overrated here? Since when

Since her fans like to pretend it's one of her Top 3 albums when its bottom 3.

[conatus]

American Life is among her best for me but I can see why it's not for everyone and I can acknowledge its flaws.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by That Bad Eartha

80s Madonna is beyond underrated on this flop site, but Erotica and Bedtime Stories are great. Confessions is def overrated though. And American Life is abysmal.

Like A Prayer the song is literally flawless. And the album is also amazing. It is cohesive and tells a story without being too narrative or samey.

Erotica isn't great, it's not even good.

But that's best saved for unpopular opinions thread I guess <3

[conatus]

Like A Virgin is one of her best albums too.

[Reverie]

I listened to American Life TWICE for the sake of Tyler's Essentials rate but once I finished I immediately went inside my brain and pressed delete

[Tom Vercetti]

Originally posted by Reverie

A lot of people say it's one of her best

Some probably have that mindset because it was somewhat done wrong by critics then. I won't say it's her most though.

[Tom Vercetti]

Originally posted by Subomie

Since her fans like to pretend it's one of her Top 3 albums when its bottom 3.

It's definitely not in the top 3, but I wouldn't say bottom two either.

[conatus]

I fail to see how someone can hate Nothing Fails though.