So apparently critics got to see the NBC midseason trailers too; THR's ranking including the fall ones:
8. Taken - Feels USA-y, and doesn't capture the film's vibe.
7. Great News - Over-relies on one gag, and the characters seem to be from 2 different shows.
6. Powerless - Not funny. Surface-y. Energetic.
5. Trial and Error - Probably doesn't translate well to trailer. Seems funny but the tone is unclear.
And then the top half are the ones I'm interested in:
4. Good Place - Probably gives a better sense of the pilot than the show, but the people in it are very promising.
3. Timeless - Pretty/cool visuals and actors.
2. Emerald City - Show likely won't live up to the trailer. Great and stylish.
1. This is Us - Lots of heart.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/fie...ilers-a-894490