Quote:
Originally posted by Doc
All this extrapolation.  I already broke this video down WITHOUT assumptions and inferences.
At this last segment that you're talking about at 3:00, Jay and Bey appear to be talking about something. What? Who knows, no one knows, not you not I, and we're not going to infer. Julius holds Solange back and then walks out first. Beyoncé and Jay BOTH approach the exit, but then Jay falls back for whatever reason. Again, neither you nor I can say why, and we certainly cannot make this assumption that Bey "quite willingly ditches" 
The second Bey steps out, Solange raises her hand and points her finger in Jay's face. Jay pushes her arm out of his face, which sets Solange off again. So yes, while Jay did touch her first, she clearly started that particular physical aggression. Bey and Julius quickly walk back in between the two. Beyoncé pushes her arms outwards in both directions, pushing Solange to one side and Julius (who is holding back Jay) to the other. Where you're getting that she is "only focused on the bodyguard", I don't know, but we simply cannot infer that from the video.
Bey then stands right in front of Solange, keeping her back, while she has a conversation with Jay again. Once more, neither you nor I can say what she was saying to Jay. It's ridiculous to even attempt to like you did. We also cannot say that she is pointing towards the exit, when she is holding a purse and has her hand up the entire exchange. For all we know she's talking with her hands. Again, we simply cannot assume these things. The bodyguard pulls Jay out the elevator, Bey is the next closest person to the exist so she leaves, and then Solange follows.
That's literally ALL you can get from the video. Everything else is baseless and unsubstantiated.
Now take off your detective hat and chill, sis.  |
First off, I was addressing a comment about how Beyonce was wildly trying to defend Jay and only had the opportunity after the first elevator departure They said that she didn't want to leave the elevator, I said she was quite willing to leave the elevator, it seemed to be her main goal. Context.
Second, I said (generally) everything you said, except I went one step further. Maybe you've been missing the last 185 pages, but there's some pretty consistent theories that I think are damaging/nonsense. I gave a plausible reason - she was just trying to get them out of the elevator. I was trying to curb the rumors that "Beyonce is on drugs", "Bey doesn't care for her man", "Jay-Z is a wife beater", "Jay-Z cheats on Bey and Bey doesn't speak up about it" assumptions in here by giving the simple minded people the basic, Ockham's razor (KISS - Keep It Simple, Stupid), problem solving explanation: Bey just thought there was a better time and place to address the issue. You can't let people fill in the blanks on ATRL or they keep it against your fave forever. You seem mildly intelligent and probably have already picked up on this. Lots of parrots on here. How long do you have to deal with ideas on ATRL like "Lady Gaga is pretentious" "Britney is a robot" or "Christina Aguilera screams" when they don't really make much sense? The majority of users on here can't handle reading between the lines, you have to spell things out for them. Give it a week, Beyonce will be called "catatonic" for the rest of the year to support the "Bey doesn't sing with emotion" claim and Jay-Z will be a "wife beater" if you don't popularize other explanations. But by all means, cut down the reasonable explanation that Beyonce was probably just trying to get everyone home so they could deal with the issue in private like the classy woman that she is.
It's obviously an assumption since I
clearly state that we'll never know what happened. I feel all weird about the BeyHive right now, ya'll are normally such a sensible bunch but you came at me for defending Bey. Very cute btw, that the last few pages calmed down pretty dramatically when it was a **** storm of random assumptions before I posted. People are so intimidated by walls of text & reasoning, it's really depressing. I understand that it does take the fun out of everything.
edit: btw I'm not coming for you Doc. I agree with everything you said, we actually know nothing & probably will never know anything about this incident. Just making that clear.
I wasn't even looking it at it from that point of view. 
