NO!, You and I is a song for a contemporary adult demography, GaGa's demography is young people who loves pop dance music, and those are the facts, not because you love the song it means is going to be successful i love Bloody Mary but i know it will flop, and i loved some tracks in The Fame Monster but i knew it would flop! Europe won't eat You and I. Australia either, Asia don't think so, so you want a single only for America (and i don't think is going to be that successful in America to be honest), you have to be realistic, GaGa's singles are successful when they sound like a GAGA SONG, POP DANCE is what the general public wants now! Adele is an exception, Gaga is not Adele!
Why shouldn't Europe eat You and I up?
It's by far not my favorite song by her, but it will do okay. What you're saying is non-sense.
And why is Adele an exception? Did you ever hear about Norah Jones or Amy Winehouse? You And I is no Adele song anyway, it will do good and I'm not here for single sales, I want her to sell her album and You And I will do exactly this.
It went to the Top 10 in iTunes in multiple countries. It's not bad for her to gain new people interests.
Someday she'll be too old for these dance-tracks. What do you want her to release then? BR 12.0?
She has to start to introduce different tracks by her to the public because it will be too late someday.
Yes maybe you are right, but look at the singles that are selling the most this year pop dance tracks, except Adele's singles, GaGa was known for singing pop dance music, look at Poker Face and Bad Romance success, the production, pop greatness, I love Born This Way album but i think there's not so many single choices, I'm sorry is just that i got used to see GaGa dominating I tunes with her singles and i don't want her to flop, she needs to stay relevant if she wants longevity and she needs an smash hit this era besides Born This Way, and sadly i don't think You And I is not going to be an smash hit, Hair either, Schiza is going to be HUGE in Europe and Marry The Night is going to be a great single, those are the songs that are going to keep this album selling, after those singles die they can release whatever the **** they want is just my opinion, I hope you guys understand my concerns!
Sorry, this is the biggest contradiction ever.
If she wants to have longevity as an artist, the smartest thing to do would be releasing You and I.
No one ever said You and I will be a smash hit, and it doesn't have to be one. It will contradict to her album sales and it will widen her fanbase. That's what an artist really needs, not a big smash single.
Hey, if there were to be a video for Scheisse, what concept would you like to apply to it?
I would love her to be an East Berlin hooker intorducing a West German guy from the bourgeoisie to hard core night life in Berlin, with EPIC scenes taking place in an underground Berlin disco playing indutstrial music in the mid nineties...
It might sound weird and cliché, but this my fantasy for that video if Scheisse becomes a single
Europe won't eat You and I. Australia either, Asia don't think so, so you want a single only for America (and i don't think is going to be that successful in America to be honest), you have to be realistic, GaGa's singles are successful when they sound like a GAGA SONG, POP DANCE is what the general public wants now! Adele is an exception, Gaga is not Adele!
and i don't want her to flop, she needs to stay relevant if she wants longevity and she needs an smash hit this era besides Born This Way, and sadly i don't think You And I is not going to be an smash hit, Hair either, Schiza is going to be HUGE in Europe and Marry The Night is going to be a great single, those are the songs that are going to keep this album selling, after those singles die they can release whatever the **** they want is just my opinion, I hope you guys understand my concerns!
