| |
Rate the American Idols: Season 5!
Member Since: 7/27/2003
Posts: 10,192
|
01 Katharine = She was excellent and the those are the only attractive floppy boobs in America. Judges should die, mainly the cold hearted snake, look into her eyes, uh-oh, she's been telling lies! DIE PAULA, DIE *****!
02 Chris = excellent vocal. He'll go all the way to the Top 2 with Kat.
03 Elliot = great vocal & song choice.
04 Paris = boring.
06 Kellie/Taylor = equally atrocious.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Taste Like Fire
Why so much hate for Paris all the time, Tina?  |
i dont hate her i just think shes highly overrated and people bash katharine and kellie, and its not fair (even tho kellie isnt that great and should be going home soon). plus her voice is fake and annoying.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Charmbracelet
i dont hate her i just think shes highly overrated and people bash katharine and kellie, and its not fair (even tho kellie isnt that great and should be going home soon). plus her voice is fake and annoying.
|
Well the bashing on Kellie I can understand  but I don't think Paris' voice fake. Yeah it can be annoying sometimes, but all of the contestants' voices can be.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
The Boys kicked the Girls’ and Taylor’s arses last night!
Katherine – Whitney Housten? Risky song choice. She did the song proudly, and put more of a performance into the song than Trenyce of Season 2 did, but I agree w/ the judges, and she didn’t hit its vocal potential. Although, I liked the performance, and she looked good n hot. (I even saw Cleve-land! *Immature LOL* ) I consider Katherine to be the best female of this season. (With regards to Paris as well.)
Elliot –Without a doubt, best performance he’s yet to give. This guy did a well, classy and cool performance once again! And he even made Paula leak! *LOL to Simon’s reaction to Paula’s critique* Congrats to him.
Kellie – WT? Unchained Melody?!! … OK lets see how this goes… (And if she need/want-ed a boyfriend, why didn’t she turn to Bucky? : P)… OK, I didn’t like it. It wasn’t strong, she didn’t dress formal-enough like the others, this song should/could cost her the competition. It seemed as if she was more focused on the high note (Which was good) instead of the rest of the song. There are better songs for her country-styled voice.
And that wasn’t fair to cut Simon off. Respect for AI producers = Minus 6 pts.
Paris – That was a nice rendition...but she came across to me as a Grandma for a sec there. ‘~”. I would like to see how her and Katherine would do if they switched their songs this week with each other, I think we would see better/more positive results. Overall she should make it to the final 4.
Taylor – I thought he was good, yet I didn’t like it. It was a nice performance, but he can not make a hit CD with that voice. This guy has charisma, which appeals his voters, but Taylor shouldn’t have gotten this far in this competition. Mandisa or Gideon should be in his spot. I don’t want to see or hear him next week. Its about time that the judges started going critical on him. Grandpa’s gotta go.
Chris – Right on / Very Good. That was a cool performance. Best of the night. Nothing more I need to say. 
Scores
Katherine – 9.05
Elliot – 9.58
Kellie – 2.2
Paris – 9.2
Taylor – 6.5
Chris – 9.89
My B2: Taylor and Kellie- I’d just send both of them home, they’re pulling this show down. –
Who I really see going
Chris = No
Elliot = Probably, but I see him going within the next 2 weeks, and he had a great performance.
Taylor = Likely No :rollseyes: But I hope so.
Katherine = Has a chance.
Paris = Likely Yes
Kellie = Likely Yes
Other Notes:
- I think next week, the final 5 will be performing 2 songs.
- My gifts to the judges this week: Randy - A thesaurus, Paula - Prozac? Ritilan?, Simon - A sling shot to use on Ryan (He could use it.) if not, just give him a PSP.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Taste Like Fire
Well the bashing on Kellie I can understand but I don't think Paris' voice fake. Yeah it can be annoying sometimes, but all of the contestants' voices can be. |
Kellie's accent is fake and so is Paris's Minnie Mouse esque.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Paris: 8.6
Elliott: 8.3
Katharine: 7.3
Kellie: 7.0
Chris: 6.9
Taylor: 6.5
Top 6:
1. Paris: 85.6 (=)
2. Kellie: 70.7 (=)
3. Elliott: 67.7 (=)
4. Chris: 65.0 (=)
5. Katharine: 60.2 (=)
6. Taylor: 58.7 (=)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
1) Katharine
2) Paris
---
3) Elliot
4) Chris
---
5) Mandisa
6) Melissa
7) Lisa
8) Kinnik
9) Will
10) Ace
11) Becky
12) Stevie
13) Brenna
14) Gedeon
15) Bucky
16) Kellie
17) Sway
18) Patrick
19) Ayla
10) Kevin
21) Heather
22) David
23) Bobby
---
24) Taylor
|
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
1) Elliott (+2)
2) Katharine (-1)
3) Chris (-1)
4) Paris (=)
5) Taylor (=)
6) Mandisa (+1)
7) Lisa (+1)
8) Melissa (+1)
9) Bucky (+1)
10) Ace (+1)
11) Kellie (-5)
12) Kevin (=)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
Top 6
01. elliot........................(+2) no denying, his best performance and best last night
02. katharine...................(-1) loved the performance, great stage presence. better than i expected
03. taylor........................(-1) enjoyed it a lot, great song pick
04. chris.........................(+1) i thought it was a bit overrated, but good performance nonetheless
05. kellie.........................(+1) wow that really bored me
06. paris..........................(-2) good vocals, bad song, bad performance, really really boring
Top 7
01. katharine................(+1) wow, great great performance
02. taylor.....................(-1) enjoyed every second of it
03. elliot......................(=) wow i really liked it a lot
04. paris......................(+2) good performance but got overshadowed by the top3
05. chris.......................(=) i thought he did good but something was missing for me
06. kellie......................(-2) wasnt as bad as everybody made out to be, but not good lol
07. ace.........................(+1) it was okay, not bad but there was nothing i enjoyed
Top 8
01. taylor................(+7) it was the most non-queen performance but i did enjoy it
02. katharine............(-1) enjoyed it a lot, a few off keys but its all good
03. elliot..................(+2) pretty good, 1 problem though he over sings a lot and too much runs
04. kellie..................(-1) it was so much better than expected but not her best
05. chris...................(-3) it was ok for me, if only he picked a better song wouldve been his moment
06. paris..................(+1) ok, nothing specially really. bad week for her once again
07. bucky..................(+2) a lot better than ace, but ofcourse i didnt enjoy it
08. ace.....................(-4) wow this sucked so bad, his stares annoy me so much
Top 9
01. katharine ............(+2) what can i say, great great great!
02. chris .................(+3) to me it was good, not great but better than the rest
03. kellie .................(+3) it was pretty enjoyable, still think she needs to lose the make up
04. ace ....................(+5) thought song fit his voice good, but he still sounds whiney to me
05. elliot ..................(+2) good nothing special
06. mandisa ...............(-4) it wasnt bad, just didnt enjoy it much
07. paris ...................(-6) it sounded way too much like karaoke to me
08. taylor ..................(-4) wow that was boring, didnt suck though
09. bucky ...................(+1) wow he ruined that song bad
Top 10
01. paris ........................ (+4) enjoyed the performance and theres no denying she can dance but it looked out of place
02. mandisa .................... (=) great performance but it sounded like she was yelling at some parts
03. katharine .................. (-2) intro worried me a lot but i did like the rest of the song, couldve done better though
04. taylor ....................... (+4) wasnt the best performance but a lot better than rest, this theme just sucks
05. chris ........................ (-1) it was okay, kinda yelled too much though
06. kellie ....................... (=) ok vocals, very boring and fire your make up stylist!
07. elliot ........................ (+2) wow what the hell was that, poser anyone? lol but yeah the best out of the sucky performance
08. lisa ......................... (-1) what happened? i dont know where the lisa i liked went
09. ace .......................... (-6) there he goes again, the whiny voice! gaahhhhh
10. bucky ........................ (=) just dont like you, please go now!
TOP 11
01. katharine ............... (=) as usual loved the performance. her voice is just amazing
02. mandisa ................. (+1) just as consistent as katharine
03. ace ........................ (+8) wow, totally made up for like everything. his past performances just sucked ass
04. chris ....................... (+2) great performance as usual, good job with the arrangement
05. paris ....................... (-1) it was very good, went down my ranking but doesnt mean it was worse than last week
06. kellie ....................... (+2) vocals getting a lot better, keep it up
07. lisa .......................... (-2) she did pretty good but got overshadowed by paris and mandisa. hope shes not bottom 3 again!
08. taylor ........................ (-6) went down in ranking a lot but he didnt do bad. he did pretty good but everyone was just really good this week
09. elliot ......................... (=) he did good but just dont like him that much. i dunno, he just hasnt impressed me
10. bucky ........................ (=) as much as his singing is far from my cup of tea, he's less annoying than harry potters and chicken littles love child
11. kevin ......................... (+1) go the fkkk away already. his nostrils and lisp is so annoying when he sings. his gf is so much better. god its so annoying seeing loser kids that are cocky!!! lolz
TOP 12
01. katharine ............ she has to win, no exception!
02. taylor .................. wow i was never a fan, but he impressed me a lot
03. mandisa .............. always great, very consistent
04. paris ................... fun performance, good vocals
05. lisa ..................... good performance, but she really needs a song to shine soon
06. chris ................... my favorite guy, but it was an ok performance
07. melissa ............... wow i was actually surprise, she made it her own, good job
08. kellie ................... was very disappointed, that wasnt the kellie i like
09. elliot ................... was never really a fan, he was ok
10. bucky .................. it was his personal best i think but his best is not good enough
11. ace ..................... he is just starting to go down faster than a rock in my bock
12. kevin ................... to me he is just a loser who thinks he's all that now, go home!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/18/2006
Posts: 22
|
1.Katherine
2.Elliot
3.Chris
4.Taylor
5.Paris
6.Kellie 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
Overall, I thought tonight was one of the better shows of the season..
1. Elliot - Home (2nd performance) Really enjoyed the rawness of the performance. Elliot's a natural born singer..
2. Chris - Renegade (1st performance) One of Chris's better performances.
3. Katherine - Black Horse and the Cherry Tree (2nd performance) MUCH MUCH better than the first performance. Little nervous when I found out she was performing it, but she did a great unique performance.
4. Elliot - On Broadway (1st performance)
5. Taylor - Play that Funky Music White Boy (1st performance) Oddest performance EVER of AI. But I liked something about it haha..
6. Paris - Kiss (1st performance)
7. Chris - I Dare You (2nd performance) Boring..
8. Katharine - Against All Odds (1st performance) Not one of her greatest moments. Off key or something..
9. Taylor - Something (2nd performance) Did anyone else find it boring? Gheesh
10. Paris - Be Without You (2nd performance) She's no Mary..
Overall for the night:
1. Elliot
2. Chris
3. Katharine
4. Taylor
5. Paris
Should be bottom 2: Taylor and Paris, with Paris going
Will be bottom 2: Katharine and Paris, with Paris going
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
WOW, Katherine sucked hard dick tonight. Poor thing. Same goes for Paris.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 11/6/2002
Posts: 10,641
|
Chris could have done an amazing job with "I Dare You", but his voice is beginning to go out on him.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
I loved Chris tonight! His voice was worn out but he's still one of the better one's, IMO.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
Great show....I liked it
1st Round (Song from the year they were born)
01.Katharine (9.5)
02.Chris (9.4)
03.Taylor (8)
04.Paris (7.5)
05.Elliot (5)
2nd Round (Song from Billboard Chart)
01.Katharine (10)
02.Chris (9.2)
03.Paris (8)
04.Taylor (7)
05.Elliot (6)
Overall:
05.Elliot
04.Taylor
03.Paris
02.Chris
01.Katharine
Should be bottom 2: Taylor and Elliot
Should go home: Elliot
Will be bottom 2: Elliot and Paris
Will Go Home: Paris
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
Most were blah, so no commentary.
1) Katharine performance #2 - Black Horse And The Cherry Tree - Rating: 8.5
2) Paris performance #2 - Be Without You - Rating: 7.5
---
3) Chris performance #1 - Renegade - Rating: 6.5
4) Elliot performance #2 - Home - Rating: 6.0
5) Paris performance #1 - Kiss - Rating: 6.0
6) Elliot performance #1 - On Broadway - Rating: 6.0
---
7) Katharine performance #1 - Against All Odds - Rating: 5.0
---
8) Chris performance #2 - I Dare You - Rating: 2.5
9) Taylor performance #1 - Play The Funky Music - Rating: 1.0
10) **Taylor performance #2 - Something - Rating: -100,000
Tonight:
1) Paris
2) Katharine
3) Elliot
4) Chris
5) Taylor
Should Be Bottom 2-3: Taylor, Chris, Elliot[3rd]
Should Get-a-steppin': Isn't it obvious?
Bottom 2-3: Paris, Elliot, Katharine[3rd]
Bye: Paris
**Worst Idol performance of the year, beating out "Takin' It To The Street" performed by the same person 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
1. kat - black horse cherry tree (amazingggg. i love that song)
2. taylor - something (great)
3. kat - aganist all odds (i think they were too harsh on this one.)
4. elliot - home
5. chris - renagdge (i think we have our new idol winner ppl.)
6. paris - be without you (she cursed)
7. elliot - on broadway
8. chris - the second song he did that was kinda bad
9. paris - kiss
10. taylor - funky music wtf?
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/1/2005
Posts: 12,107
|
My first ratings this year: (bolded one was better)
Top 5
01.Paris "Kiss/Be Without You"
02.Chris Daughtry "Renegade/I Dare You"
-gap-
03.Katherine Mcphee "Against All Odds/Black Horse And The Cherry Tree"
-gap-
04.Elliot Yamin "On Broadway/Home"
05.Taylor Hicks "Play That Funky Music/Something"
Should Leave:
Taylor Hicks
Will Leave:
Elliot Yamin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
1.Katharine- Black Horse and a Cherry Tree... very original and she sounded great on this. This is exactly her type of song...
2.Chris- Renegade... one of his best, I liked it a lot.
3.Elliot- Home... very sincere, much better than his first performance
Those three were the only SOLID performances...
4.Elliot- On Broadway... eh, pretty good.
5.Paris- Kiss... a lot of off moments in it.
6.Paris- Be Without You... not very good, and she cursed.
7.Katharine- Against All Odds... Her worst performance. I was very dissapointed. She needs to know that this isn't her type of song (she needs bluesy soulful songs, not power ballads i.e. Voice Within/I Have Nothing/Against All Odds, all her WORST performances).
8.Chris- I Dare You... VERY strained. Bad job.
9.Taylor- Play That Funky Music... WTF? That was terrible, and I'm getting really sick of his drunk antics.
10.Taylor- Something.... BIGGEST COPOUT EVER. I'm so angry... that song was done 30 years ago. Not to mention his performance was terrrrrrrible.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/27/2003
Posts: 10,192
|
01 Katharine - Black Horse & The Cherry Tree
02 Chris - Renegade
03 Elliot - Home
04 Paris - Be Without You
05 Katharine - Against All Odds
06 Taylor - Something
07 Chris - I Dare You
08 Paris - Kiss
09 Elliot - On Broadway
10 Taylor - Play That ****** Music
Overall
01 Katharine
02 Chris
03 Paris
04 Elliot
05 Taylor
Elliot and Paris are going home this week and next week. The Top 3 will definitely be Katharine, Chris, & Taylor.
|
|
|
|
|
|
