Colton should have done the whole song on the piano. When he got up and the tempo picked up he lost it a bit. His performance and his looks should be enough to get him through to next week I think.
Jeremy shouldn't have made it to the semifinals to begin with and tonight's middle of the road performance proved that.
First of all Aaron is like 30 but he was styled like a teen. I wasn't crazy about his performance like you guys were. He screams background singer to me.
Deandre was one of my favorites coming in. His range is crazy - I love his falsetto and his lower register. His performance was too casual for the Idol stage. I do hope he's voted through.
Phillip's performance was just short of "a moment". I loved it, particularly the end.
I swear I don't remember seeing Chase until now. He's just an average country singer to me. I'm not here for him but I'm sure America is
I love Heejun but he came up short for me tonight too
He needed to really BELT that song out and fill the studio with his voice.
Joshua took it to ! I think he'll do well as the other Church f*g from last year
Adam Brock's performance was too karaoke. Who the hell is his audience? Who would buy his album? That applies to many guys this year.
Eben was easily the worst of the post-audition season.
I loved Reed's performance. I loved the laid back arrangement, the drums, everything
Disappointing night overall. I hope the girls do better tomorrow. I can't wait to see what Jessica sings. 
Sidenote: After The X Factor & The Voice, Idol's live shows seem very karaoke. Even the backing tracks sound like those karaoke instrumentals you find on Youtube with the backing vocals
Best of the night EASILY.
