Anyways... here's what we know for sure about the season finale
**SPOILERS**
A probably didn't feature too heavily in the last few episodes. the usual suspects, particularly in this week's episode, were shown too prominently. they were most likely red herrings. Melissa is so damn obvious she cant be A for sure. Ezra hasnt been shown that much in the last few episodes... just saying
I think Maya is gonna die tbh. They broke her off from Emily so it wouldn't suprise me if she fell into the same hole Samara fell into.
Ok call me crazy but I've spent the last 2 days watching it from the beginning, I'm near the end of the first seaosn now - has Spencer even been directly attacked by A? I honestly think she's involved somehow. There are a lot of signs that you don't realize when you don't suspect her. Idk, it probably isn't but I just have a feeling. I think she could be one half of A trying to figure out who the killer is, or she killed her and she's trying to figure out who A is cos whoever it is knows she did it.
Spencer left the barn the night Allison disappeared. I don't think that was completely random. If she had something to do with her murder that would be beyond unexpected.
Spencer left the barn the night Allison disappeared. I don't think that was completely random. If she had something to do with her murder that would be beyond unexpected.
Yes, and if you remember they had that photo that showed Alison being followed by someone, and then Spencer came out and told the others it was her, right after they had a fight.
Quote:
Originally posted by Robertlavigne
Didn't A try frame Spencer for murder?
Or did Spencer just slip up? Or maybe A knows Spencer killer Alison. Idk, I'm just guessing really. It would be really shocking.
But now everyone has this "Melissa is too obvious" mindset, it would be surprising to the audience if she was actually A.
I know it's not her, but watching the old episodes back I had a feeling Melissa was A. Or at least one half of A.
It would be REALLY stupid if Melissa had to do ANYTHING with A. the liars now think she's A after the Caleb/Mona kiss.
Quote:
Originally posted by Guero
I've always been against him being A but seeing that list makes me rethink everything. The only thing I don't get is how none of the members of N.A.T. (Garrett, Jason, Melissa, etc.) never interact with him. The only possible link is Jenna...
Well, according to Marlene King, there have been more members of the N.A.T. club that we dont know of... Ezra & Wren possibly, they are into younger girls just like the rest of the gang
Quote:
Originally posted by Sin With A Grin
Maybe they're going to reveal the motive when they reveal A? That's just my theory. I don't know. D:
Or maybe the motive would be the point of doing season 3... there will be a lot more mysteries that need to be solved.
Quote:
Originally posted by PopBoi
Ok call me crazy but I've spent the last 2 days watching it from the beginning, I'm near the end of the first seaosn now - has Spencer even been directly attacked by A? I honestly think she's involved somehow. There are a lot of signs that you don't realize when you don't suspect her. Idk, it probably isn't but I just have a feeling. I think she could be one half of A trying to figure out who the killer is, or she killed her and she's trying to figure out who A is cos whoever it is knows she did it.
Actually... Aria's the one who hasnt been targeted that much... Spencer has suffered a LOT. she's been a person of interest in Ali's murder, she had to break up with Toby & Alex, the guy from the country club.
I think Maya is gonna die tbh. They broke her off from Emily so it wouldn't suprise me if she fell into the same hole Samara fell into.
Maya is not the one who dies. she wasnt even supposed to be in the finale, but apparently, she is Idk why would she lie. here's what Bianca said:
Quote:
“My absolute honest answer is that I have no idea who dies. I’m not in the finale, and the way I’ve always gotten my information about Maya is when I get the script. So I don’t know who “A” is; I don’t know who dies; I’ll be finding out with everyone else!”
“My absolute honest answer is that I have no idea who dies. I’m not in the finale, and the way I’ve always gotten my information about Maya is when I get the script. So I don’t know who “A” is; I don’t know who dies; I’ll be finding out with everyone else!”
^^^^does that mean we can automatically rule Maya out as A or any sort of helper?
I always thought she was in the NAT club. It looked too weird, the way she was just randomly talking to Jason that day and nobody made any comment about it.
^^^^does that mean we can automatically rule Maya out as A or any sort of helper?
I always thought she was in the NAT club. It looked too weird, the way she was just randomly talking to Jason that day and nobody made any comment about it.
Maya isnt A because she wasnt in the first 8 episodes of season 2. A was in some of those episodes so there's NO way Maya is A.
Well there's a theory Maya never went to that camp. some fans think she was living with Jason & thats the reason why his windows were covered with newspaper. but idk... some fans even think she's a private investigator hired by Jason because Maya in real life has 32 years old
I meant to say Melissa in that "watching old episodes" post, which is why I went on about Spencer in the next one.
Quote:
Originally posted by Katie
Melissa isn't A, but she's Ali's killer. Quote me
This is what I said at the end of Season 1. Melissa caught Ali sleeping with Ian and killed her, he helped cover it up, hence all the "I'm doing it for us!" he did right before he was pushed in the bell tower.
Quote:
Originally posted by MsCherry
Actually... Aria's the one who hasnt been targeted that much... Spencer has suffered a LOT. she's been a person of interest in Ali's murder, she had to break up with Toby & Alex, the guy from the country club.
Aria's always being targeted by A. Whenever something happens to Spencer (which is rare) she never gets a text from A, the other girls always do. I don't remember A making her do those things. Like I said, I'm just making guesses. I think theres a reason she was outside of the barn and the reason the flashback cut off when Spencer ran outside after her after their arguement about Ian.
Aria's always being targeted by A. Whenever something happens to Spencer (which is rare) she never gets a text from A, the other girls always do. I don't remember A making her do those things. Like I said, I'm just making guesses. I think theres a reason she was outside of the barn and the reason the flashback cut off when Spencer ran outside after her after their arguement about Ian.
Are we watching the same show?
- she was almost accused of killing her friend
- A broke her relationship with Alex
- the whole hotel thing with Toby and Spencer
- after Spencer pawns her sister's diamond ring for what she hopes is only 48 hours, A finds the cash to buy it from the pawn shop owner
- A put Ian's phone in Spencer's bag, making Melissa think Spencer was the one who was texting her & pretending to be Ian
- A made Spencer to break up w Toby in the first part of season 2 finale
- A made Spener to break up with Toby yet again after A sent him to hospital
- Spencer is the main target of A being the one he or she has tried the most times to frame or even kill. This is most likely since Spencer is the only one who could ever stand up to Alison
- Spencer has received 19 individual messages from A. out of all 4 girls, Aria has received the fewest messages from A, 15.
Sure, Spencer isnt targeted as much as Emily & Hanna, but she is more than Aria.
Quote:
Originally posted by Katie
Melissa isn't A, but she's Ali's killer. Quote me
I can see that happening, but it would be SO lame if she was the killer.
Even the girls & Melissa's parents at some point thought she was the killer. it wouldnt be shocking to learn that she was the killer.
Quote:
Originally posted by Guero
The girl who unmasks herself at the end... Maya or Jenna?
Toby
Ezra
Caleb
Wren
Aira's brother(wasn't he chatting with someone online, acting a mess for a while and stealing etc.?)
Aria's dad
Garret
Jason
The Cop
Toby
Ezra
Caleb
Wren
Aira's brother(wasn't he chatting with someone online, acting a mess for a while and stealing etc.?)
Aria's dad
Garret
Jason
The Cop
I posted a blog post on tumblr on why I think Ezra and Wren are A and my ask box is getting attacked by anons who think I'm an idiot
We'll see how things transgress. XD
Toby
Ezra
Caleb
Wren
Aira's brother(wasn't he chatting with someone online, acting a mess for a while and stealing etc.?)
Aria's dad
Garret
Jason
The Cop
WHo am I missing?
Wait. There's a guy who's a "big liar"?
Where did you hear this?