[BGKC]

Originally posted by G.U.Y. Gaga

If you have Rihanna in there you definitely need Beyoncé up there

Also isn't it funny that throughout this conversation that no one mentioned P!nk once, her impact is just , I really am surprised how she remains successful tbh...

Alicia Keys too.
Both P!nk and AK outlasted Britney/Xtina, yet they fly under ATRL's radar.

[Icing]

Originally posted by BGKC

Taylor will probably outlast her too.

Yes! And the Lord only gets more global with every era. She'll go down as the biggest female country legend ever when all is said and done. GranDolly and Shanovoice can fall back

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by Save-Me-Oprah

In the music world? Sure. He's ascended to royal status in the Country world.

Just making sure we are not having any pop girl delusions in this thread, especially if we are counting Shania...

[rihannafan]

Originally posted by GreasyBruce

At Rihanna being a legend

More famous than Bruce (whose existence was revealed to me through ATRL)

[Nicole]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

It kinda is. And keep in mind that Shania didn't had such a massive movie like Titanic to back her up.

But the movie is also why it's more remembered and beloved than the Shania song. People have a strong emotional connection to the song because of the movie, which continues to live on (the 3D re-release grossed ~$350M in 2012).

[iheartBrit]

Originally posted by FAME.

The Spice Girls and Backstreet Boys are more comparable to BRITNEY than Shania.

Actually no. Spice Girls and BSB stopped getting big hits after the 90s like Shania. Britney outlasted them all.

[Icing]

Bruce is such a legend at my uni. I think it's cuz I'm so close to Jersey. EVERYYYYONE went to his show at Meadowlands.

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by rihannafan

More famous than Bruce (whose existence was revealed to me through ATRL)

Now sis you are going way to far now....

[FAME.]

Originally posted by Nicole

But the movie is what makes it more remembered and beloved than the Shania song. People have a strong emotional connection to the song because of the movie, which continues to live on (the 3D re-release grossed ~$350 in 2012).

But had the music supervisors chosen I Will Always Love You or any other ballad for that scene, MHWGO wouldn't be nearly as rememered.

IFLAW and You're Still The One have achieved their remembrance all on their own.

[johnsuxx]

Thanks for this discussion, it's got me listening to true classics like That Don't Impress Me Much, You're Still the One and Man! I Feel Like a Woman!

Poor Britney

[GreasyBruce]

Originally posted by rihannafan

More famous than Bruce (whose existence was revealed to me through ATRL)

So more people know of her yet she can't gross 1/3rd on tour? So they know her but they REJECTED her?

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by Kworb

No, that's the whole point, tours are not a good indicator of overall impact. They just show that the artist has many fans. But to be known/remembered beyond that you need memorable songs.

Their youtube receipts are pathetic, it's clear that Depeche Mode are unused by the GP. Legends only in their niche.

They HAVE memorable songs. If you don't know/like them then it's your problem. Everyone know Enjoy the Silence, Personal Jesus, Just Can't Get Enough, etc. And yes, touring power is a GREAT indicator of overall impact, we use the same case with Madonna, U2, etc.

They don't have a proper YT page, some of it is on Vevo, some of it on their label's chanel, and others in random accounts. And this YT views ******** never work, people try to use it with Madonna just to embarrass themselves.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Before ATRL I thought Bruce Springsteen was a bigger star than he actually is. He was always third fiddle to MJ and Prince. How sad

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by FAME.

But had the music supervisors chosen I Will Always Love You or any other ballad for that scene, MHWGO wouldn't be nearly as rememered.

IFLAW and You're Still The One have achieved their remembrance all on their own.

Does this really matter tho

A hit song is kind of a hit song, and there are plenty of movies that don't have songs as remembered as MHWGO or IWALY.....

[satellites.™]

I remember when April Fools Day on ATRL used to be a complete and utter foolish mess.

The new girls are a bit boring no?

[BAYAR]

This "you're pressed" thing is so dull and overrated to use when people know they're dead wrong or just being extremely deluded. Like, you just read a post completely tearing your long ass statement to shreds and you come back with that. Fail more.

[Vin]

Diet Mountain Dew, baby, New York City.
Never was there ever a girl so pretty.
Do you think we’ll be in love forever?
Do you think we’ll be in love?



...Vin

[Save-Me-Oprah]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Actually no. Spice Girls and BSB stopped getting big hits after the 90s like Shania. Britney outlasted them all.

Just because their success was less recent than Britney's doesn't make Britney more of a legend than Shania.

Is Adele a legend?

[2stupid4you]

Originally posted by satellites.™

I remember when April Fools Day on ATRL used to be a complete and utter foolish mess.

The new girls are a bit boring no?

aren't you the one who created talisa?

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by satellites.™

I remember when April Fools Day on ATRL used to be a complete and utter foolish mess.

The new girls are a bit boring no?

Everyone is already too messy on a daily bases, if they/me were any messier we'd all be banned with almost 1 post