[Ramcoro]

This is stupid. You can't compare someone that has 3X the amount of albums.

[Robert]

Katy

[GangstaR]

Rihanna Of course !

[the floacist]

Rihanna I guess

[Ryou Itaru Hou]

Rihanna

[AnotherGagaFan]

this one is so hard...but i'd say Rihanna.

(they're both nowhere near icons)

[Chris191]

Originally posted by Jolie's Lips

Yet Pink's Greatest Hits outsold some of the other media hyped girls' latest releases.

And at least it took P!nk a few years to be forgotten. Ke$ha was pretty much over when Tik Tok stopped charting on the Billboard Hot 100.

She isn't forgotten, but still,

& Rihanna, quite easily

[Wilkes]

Rihanna.

[Ramcoro]

I think you should have compared Kesha and Katy then Pink and Rihanna. Those are more fair me thinks.

[pink.hearts]

I feel like they're similar minus rihanna being here longer, so i'd give it to rihanna

[ManyUses]

It's unfair but I'll go with Rihanna. It should have been Katy vs. Gaga, or something rather.

[zzmyth]

Rihanna by far.

[Loghen]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

I think you should have compared Kesha and Katy then Pink and Rihanna. Those are more fair me thinks.

This.

[Remixed]

Neither are even close to being iconic

I guess Rihanna because she's been around longer

[HausOfGerard]

Rihanna .

[loco]

None of them are iconic at all.

What is it with your first post announcing SHakira winning with ? Biased much?

[UnusualBoy]

I'll go with Rihanna for being around more time ahd releasing more album.

[PurrKaty]

Thats a stupid comparision, Rihannas first hit big in 2005, Katy has really only been around since 2008. Rihanna has had twice as much time to establish herself, plus she has had 6 albums, katy really only has 2 ablums. How about you ask this comparision in 2-3 more years, then i would actually be able to compare the 2 artists. DUMB QUESTION!!!!

[RatedG²]

Easily Rihanna

[2AM]

The one with six albums, vs two.