[jafet]

Originally posted by ♥CEB♥

Are you really trying to say that it was her back-up singers that helped sell those albums?

oh ok!

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Very true. And I applaud her for that. But I disagree when you say that she sold 30 million albums by combining Destiny child sales. You might as well combine the sales of the soundtrack of dreamgirls as well....

Well, technically, those sales do count for her. But the OP and title say it all.

[Britneyfan09]

Originally posted by jafet

yes and also she is the only pop start with over a carrear of over 10 year to past the 2 million world wide sales with her latest work, even worst she will be the only pop girl with more than a decade in the game to have all her solo album open in more than 300k, even worst she is the only female artist with over a decade in the business to have a album that sold over 700k in the USA.in 2011!!!!!!:alexz:

No she isn't but this is just ridiculous.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by ♥CEB♥

Are you really trying to say that it was her back-up singers that helped sell those albums?

Back-up singers or not. They were still a group and they will always be known as a group.

[Jolie's Lips]

Originally posted by Alexz

12 million

That's an average of 3 million per album.

Is that more or less than Britney's average per album since her 4 studio album releases since 2003?

[jafet]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Very true. And I applaud her for that. But I disagree when you say that she sold 30 million albums by combining Destiny child sales. You might as well combine the sales of the soundtrack of dreamgirls as well....

Well when people talk about LA reid they said he has sold 200million of record and he dosent event sing on non of those record!!!

And the article says that beyonce carrer total is 30M not her solo work!!!!!

She is one person and she form part of the grup and wrote and co-wrote a lot of them song so she deserve to say that she has sold those record, just like kelly deserve to say it and michell

[caerbayn]

Beyoncé is DC. She wrote everything, sung everything and did everything right down to physically being in the recording booth with the other members to make sure they'd lay down the the vocals correctly.

[jafet]

Originally posted by Britneyfan09

No she isn't but this is just ridiculous.

tell me somebody that have been more than 10 year in the game that is a female have sold more than her?!

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

You might as well combine the sales of the soundtrack of dreamgirls as well....

Thanks for reminding me let me tell sats to add them to the first page.

[KORDEI]

Only if people could READ and see the "+DC" in the thread title. :kisuke:

[Alexz]

Originally posted by jafet

tell me somebody that have been more than 10 year in the game that is a female have sold more than her?!

Do you really want him to tell you?

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by jafet

Well when people talk about LA reid they said he has sold 200million of record and he dosent event sing on non of those record!!!

And the article says that beyonce carrer total is 30M not her solo work!!!!!

She is one person and she form part of the grup and wrote and co-wrote a lot of them song so she deserve to say that she has sold those record, just like kelly deserve to say it and michell

Hmm ok. well 12 million or 30 million. She is still a respectable popular artist and I'm happy for her success.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by jafet

tell me somebody that have been more than 10 year in the game that is a female have sold more than her?!

Uhm.... Kelly Clarkson and Britney Spears

[jafet]

Originally posted by Jolie's Lips

That's an average of 3 million per album.

Is that more or less than Britney's average per album since her 4 studio album releases since 2003?

is in it funny that since beyonce went solo britney lost it all, dance move, hair, sex appeal, intellect if she had one at some point, record sales etc.

beyonce reign and britney fall in a has been with the same age!!!!!!

[jafet]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Uhm.... Kelly Clarkson and Britney Spears

how much kelly has sold, and last time i check britney was at 650K
well then i raised to 800k and im damn sure non of them has reach that!

[LightandDarkness]

Originally posted by jafet

yes and also she is the only pop start with over a carrear of over 10 year to past the 2 million world wide sales with her latest work, even worst she will be the only pop girl with more than a decade in the game to have all her solo album open in more than 300k, even worst she is the only female artist with over a decade in the business to have a album that sold over 700k in the USA.in 2011!!!!!!

No ma'am.

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

My point exactly. Beyonce was a part of DC but Beyonce isn't DC. Destiny's child sold 17 million. Not beyonce sold 17 million. Not Kelly sold 17 million. Not Michelle sold 17 million. TOGETHER they sold 17 million.

They also won Grammys TOGETHER.
But NARAS give them all their own separate award.

[jafet]

Originally posted by LightandDarkness

No ma'am.

im talking this year!

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

You might as well combine the sales of the soundtrack of dreamgirls as well....

Let me go add those to the first page right now.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by jafet

how much kelly has sold, and last time i check britney was at 650K
well then i raised to 800k and im damn sure non of them has reach that!

Oh I thought you were talking about whole carreer who has sold more.

Kelly her album has been out for just two months and has about 400k with just one hit single. So I will be answering that question when the album peaked