Quote:
Originally posted by Mrnoniee
Critics( whose opinion matters more than yours) beg to differ
There's your answer.
GL is a mess of an album.
People expected a TBDT 2.0 after 5million copies of it sold.
and they got an album full of mellow songs.
Mellow songs in AL >>>>> Mellow songs on GL
AL has better songwriting than GL and its a FACT. Don't even try it. GYWYL> GL album
GL is also packed with cheap songs. She has cheap songs in every album except UMS
AL's cover > GL's mess (what was even that?)
If you don't agree then make a thread and ask the member to vote for the best album cover out of the two. You'll see the result yourself.
and both album don't have a theme. I'm not saying AL is her best album its just AL is better than GL.
|
That's because only 9 critics bothered to review "Avril Lavigne" compared to 14 for "Goodbye Lullaby" and honestly I don't get how
83 - 82 - 70 - 70 - 60 - 60 - 60 - 30 - 20 =
65 (when in average it is 59.5)
and
70 - 70 - 69 - 67 - 63 - 60 - 60 - 60 - 60 - 50 - 50 - 50 - 42 - 40 =
58 (average is really 58)
I should contact mediacritic so they put AL into yellow zone where it belongs.
GL ballads > AL ballads. GYWYL is a good song but an average ballad for her career. What's so special about it? It just stands up because it is the best track on AL.
Just because songwriting of GYWYL is (questionably) good, doesn't mean AL has better songwriting than GL. Just look at rhe lyrics Hello Kitty, YASNY or SoS.
GL is not packed with cheap songs (maybe Smile is one) cos it is packed with ballads and they are supposed to be stripped down. However AL tried to have these uptempos and summer songs but they r so cheap
GL cover and booklet are beau....cleanse ur eyes pls. AL is just her vampire bleached face zoomed in like ****.