Quote:
Originally posted by Madam X
So what if she is more successful than them right now? She is only catching up to their already huge success. No one cares for Pink outside of her "hits". Britney and Xtina are considered pop legends while Pink isn't even regarded as an icon, and that is the sad truth. Accept it already.
|
Catching up? Christina and Britney have their explosive debut albums. P!nk has outsold them and put more hits on the charts since 2001. She has also toured with better numbers and has more acclaim from critics. Nobody considers Britney or Christina legends, outside of their fans. They've been out for 16 years. Try calling them legends in 2025 or later and see if anybody mentions them like people do Elvis, Willie Nelson etc.
Quote:
Originally posted by conatus
she does have a good voice, but it feels like she's made little impact and little artistic growth over her career.
|
P!nk has actually changed exponentially since her debut. She started with DAT R&B music and has subtly changed genres time and again. Not only in music but also in her stage shows has P!nk evolved, pushing the boundaries of the live show
Quote:
Originally posted by Prismatic
P!nk has already caught up with Xtina since 2008 and Britney in 2011. She's way ahead of both of them now.
|
She "caught up" with them as soon as the teen pop boom ended. But thanks for your tea
Quote:
Originally posted by Grumpy Gills
What kinda lie, she might be more successful than them now but overall it's a no.
|
According to Wikipedia, Christina has sold 17 million domestic albums and 50 million worldwide. Rough numbers for P!nk are 16 million domestically, 45 million worldwide and 65 million singles worldwide, without the benefit of the teen pop boom. But like it's been said, she's more successful. She's not just carried by the success of her first couple of albums like Brit and Christina are. She's steadily moved an average of 2.5 million albums per era in the US.
So what matters more? Having a couple big albums and then faltering or having some big albums along with competitive album sales?