ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 11/5/2011
Posts: 100,491
|
ATRL'S What's My Song? Season 1
Episode 1: Who Are YOU?
This episode, you had to show us who you are based on a song you chose from the June 2, 2012 Hot 100 listing. Did you win over your peers, the "GP" and me? Let's find out.
All raw scores (peer votes, and GP votes, my votes/rankings) were converted to a normalized score, which will determine your ranking for this episode .
Before we begin, let's check out a few comments from your fellow peers:
Quote:
I would've voted for fierce for the worst, but there's something about his entry that feels right. It feels straightforward.  Prismatic, JakeKills, prezli, Superpower, and Element are definitely my favorites for this round. I love Johnny Mac's layout. I don't like the song that much, but it's not something I hold against him. His explanation was nice anyway. I guess that's pretty much it. 
|
Quote:
Best: JakeKills
The last sentence 
The gif 
Worst: Fierce
You seem to not want to be here so let me help you pack your bags. |
Quote:
|
Worst: it's hard because there were several that were all like equally low, but I think I've gotta go with musiclover. His writing really wasn't that strong, especially compared to Bloomers—who had the same song and one of the strongest entries.
|
Quote:
|
My least favorite entry this round was: Loveyoubxtch - We Run The Night. I felt like the description could apply to a lot of different songs and I really didn't get a feeling for how the song represented the member.
|
Quote:
|
So sorry, late last night I got home from vacation and I just passed out
Best : Prismatic
I can obviously see the effort and the words were great (Johnny Mac would be my 2nd vote but yeah)
Worst: - musiclover -
Take care was chosen like 8 times and this was my least favorite of it, it was just too boring and I didn't really feel a connection to it
|
Quote:
|
Positive vote for wesleywalrus cause he really relates himself on the song
Negative vote for Lucky#17 cause the explanation has too much lyrics from the song. I cannot understand it clearly.
|
To recap:
-the winner of the peer vote was a tie between Prismatic and Johnny Mac.
-the winner of the GP vote was wesleywalrus.
-the winner of my vote/rank was Prismatic.
So, who wins this episode?
1. Prismatic - 30.875
Congratulations! Although you did not score any votes from the GP, your peers and myself felt that you were great enough to pass to the next episode. AS A RESULT OF YOUR TOP CALLOUT THIS WEEK, you have the liberty to select the Hot 100 chart for the next episode! You can only pick a chart that occurs in the 2010s. PM me your choice ASAP.
Although Prismatic gets to pick the chart, you all (including Prismatic) will still be given a random number, which will then correspond to the position/song that you'll have to use for the next round.
let's move on to the remaining contestants that will move on to the second episode...
2. Johnny Mac - 29.875
3. JakeKills - 24.375
4. wesleywalrus - 24.125
5. Element - 22.125
6. Bloomers - 22
7. jpow - 21.5
8. HausofNiko - 21
9. HausOfLuke - 20.625
10. Legend E - 20.5
11. Superpower - 20.375
12. Scene. - 18.75
13. Lucky#17 - 18.25
14. JustLuke - 17.75
15. Loveyoubxtch - 17.25
16. Xedretinz Lododnz - 15.25
17. prezli - 14
18. rl231 - 13.75
....
The bottom two this week are -mUsIcLoVeR- and fiercE.
-mUsIcLoVeR-, some of your peers felt that you could have given more life to your entry, and fiercE, even though you snagged a few of the GP votes, your peers felt that your entry was less than adequate, so who stays?
19. -mUsIcLoVeR- - 11.75
Congrats on making it through! Be sure to step up to the plate for your next entry.
--
fiercE - even though simplicity is key sometimes, it would have been nice for you to elaborate a bit on your song choice like your peers did. Thanks for joining and deciding to play!
--
Stay tuned for details on Episode 2 and that round's special guest judge
|
|
|
|
I liked musiclover's entry though. 
and some of the entries explain why they are here not who they are 
