[pride4jc1222]

I've known all along that You and I would be the 4th single, and that Marry the Night would be the 5th. You and I is going to be more successful than Marry the Night.

[Moonage Daydream]

It's easily the best song on the album, and while I'm glad that she would consider it as a single, I just hope that it doesn't become the next single. I think she should save it as the final single, that way she can end the BTW era with a bang. Save the best for last, I say.


And she should really take a break and disappear from the public eye for a bit once she's done promoting this album. Because she's really bordering on overexposure now.

[genetic fail]

i think it's too early for You & I to be released.
there has to be more hype 1st!

like release Americano, the sequel to Telephone

[Human Nature]

Originally posted by genetic FEH-E-AIL

i think it's too early for You & I to be released.
there has to be more hype 1st!

like release Americano, the sequel to Telephone

Ugh, Americano would be the perfect sequel to Telephone.

[Gui Blackout]

Well then she betta release a acustic/live version, i don't use that ****** album version.

[Bathomet]

I still don' understand what the point of releasing this. As a single it will only have moderate sucess, and it won't really push the album sales as the rest of the album is cheap eurotrash.

[BTrisc]

Nah. IMO, Scheiße would be the perfect sequel to Telephone. The song perfectly fits the theme: girls aren't allowed to be bad, so they need permission when they want to be. Gaga just wants to be bad, but the Popo won't let it happen.

[Tantei]

If she really wants to release 8 singles or more she should do it like this...
- Scheiße...end of august..slaying everyone at the VMAs and getting that #1..
- Yoü And I ..winter single..getting album sales..
- Marry The Night..as her spring single
- Americano..summer smash..continuation of the telephone video..
- then end the era with Bloody Mary ..
New album..at the end of 2013

[Fearless]

Have we really gone 16 friggin pages without a mention of GODDESS HALEY's cover of it on AI?

But anyways, it's probably my second favorite song on the album after TEOG, so it sounds good to me if true.

[t.A.T.u.]

REALLYYYYYYY?OMG THIS PLEASE BE TRUEE IF THIS HAPPENS THIS WILL BE MY FAV SONG OF 2011

[longjohn9898]

Originally posted by Bathomet

I still don' understand what the point of releasing this. As a single it will only have moderate sucess, and it won't really push the album sales as the rest of the album is cheap eurotrash.

Awww, the Katy Perry stan is throwing shades as bitchy and unfounded as his idol's.

[longjohn9898]

Originally posted by Tantei

If she really wants to release 8 singles or more she should do it like this...
- Scheiße...end of august..slaying everyone at the VMAs and getting that #1..
- Yoü And I ..winter single..getting album sales..
- Marry The Night..as her spring single
- Americano..summer smash..continuation of the telephone video..
- then end the era with Bloody Mary ..
New album..at the end of 2013

I like this. But I don't know if I can wait that long for Marry the Night to smash!

[TREMendo]

I don't like the Nebraska part at the end, I mean taht was like very.. random o.O

[Wick]

I agree with most people: save it for last. After Judas flopped and TEOG isn't big pop dance song, she needs Marry the Night next to save face a bit (not a diss to beloved TEOG, but she needs to remind people of why she's so big and deliver what she does best). Then show off her talent with You and I, sixth. (Hair can be fifth).

[Glamthony]

AWESOME! this is my third fav song on the album! and i'm sure i'll be a hit!

[ↁЄℛЄƘ]

Not here for anything produced by Mutt.
Unless its sung by Shania.

[Nicole]

Originally posted by Wick

I agree with most people: save it for last. After Judas flopped and TEOG isn't big pop dance song, she needs Marry the Night next to save face a bit (not a diss to beloved TEOG, but she needs to remind people of why she's so big and deliver what she does best). Then show off her talent with You and I, sixth. (Hair can be fifth).

It's funny b/c people were always saying she needs to release a single that's NOT a typical pop dance song by RedOne.

[Delita_chan]

I thought she mentioned that "Hair" would be released next (or so it's been insinuated here on ATRL). Both songs are good, though I don't know that the younger generation would eat up "You and I" They want their pop/dance/fun/mindless tunes that currently saturate the radio (not that it's a bad thing).

"Hair" is one that I think might have a better chance. It is true what someone typed here on ATRL in the Gaga thread - non-ATRLers seem to like this song. I used the song in a slideshow for about close to 300 kids and many of them really REALLY liked it.

[Tysen]

This thread goes to show how people stan for Gaga's success and not her. They can't even enjoy **** she does unless it does well commercially

[Wick]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

It's funny b/c people were always saying she needs to release a single that's NOT a typical pop dance song by RedOne.

She took that to an extreme