Poker Face has already outlasted Bad Romance so your prediction is already off. Anyhow, Gaga kinda lacks true classics in comparison to her peers. She really is the Madonna of our generation.
LAP did "worse" than its predecessor... Same with "Music"
That means absolutely nothing. A 4m+ album and 2 singles exceeding 10m sales is a highly successful era.
We are not in the 80's or 90's honey, but considering Red sold like 5M and 1989 is at 8M you might be right. So that means LG5 will do better than ArtPoop? I take that!
Prediction, when is said and done Gags and katy will have only one memorable hit each Bad Romance and Firework.
but this isnt even one of her more memorable hits now. so will everyone forget all of her actually remembered hits, and then suddenly realize this one exists?
Roar is gonna be HNC kind of relevant in the future (it's still doing 10m per month on YouTube + it'll soon be her 4th 6m seller and 4th diamond single) but she's not getting another firework unless EDIAH gets Dark Horse kind of approval despite being an ad jingle but that's never happened before so...
You are letting Remixed fool you, I know he's a huge Poker Face stan and he might influenced you but Bad Romance is much bigger, complex, anthemic and memorable hit. You can argue all you want but that's just the truth...