[fabbriche]

Originally posted by Satellites

Ummmm Oprah, Obama, Diana Ross, Whitney Houston, Chaka Chan, Patti Labelle, Tina Turner, Prince, Michael Jackson, and etc...

Did they commend Beyonce's vocals or her performances and stage presence alone? 'Cause they are two different things. Sorry I don't follow Beyonce. But I know Whitney also commended Christina's vocals. And that is the biggest compliment a singer can get coming from 2 of the greatest divas. The only diva that did not commend Christina for is Mariah because they're not in good terms with each other.

Originally posted by PopBoi

DEAD at people saying Mariah is a better singer than Beyonce

When Mariah was Beyonce's age, she was magnificent vocally. And besides, only 4 pop stars are true sopranos - Mariah, Celine, Whitney and Christina. Mariah has 7-octave vocal range. The other 3 have 5 octaves. Beyonce has 3 octaves only. The above 4 could belt out high notes that Beyonce could never. No wonder why she doesn't have much ballad songs.

[PopBoi]

Originally posted by fabbriche

When Mariah was Beyonce's age, she was magnificent vocally. And besides, only 4 pop stars are true sopranos - Mariah, Celine, Whitney and Christina. Mariah has 7-octave vocal range. The other 3 have 5 octaves. Beyonce has 3 octaves only. The above 4 could belt out high notes that Beyonce could never. No wonder why she doesn't have much ballad songs.

Beyonce had a whole disc dedicated to ballads in her last album, she has plenty

I actually think that in 20 -30 years Beyonce will still be able to belt out like she does now, I can't see her losing her voice for a LONG time.

[fabbriche]

Funny thing is I could not tell the difference between Beyonce and Kelly's voice during their Destiny's Child era. They almost sounded the same. But I must admit that Beyonce's vocals has greatly improved now. She can do a lot of vocal gymnastics that a real diva can. Must be constant vocal lessons, training and practice paying off.

[SwagLikeALegend]

Originally posted by Celestial

At her peak, Mariah was way better than Beyonce. Mariah's losing her voice, it's not what it used to be. Someday Beyonce will be in the same position.

She's 40, obviously her voice is going to weaken over time.

[KarlosVzla]

There's no comparison... Adele>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Love Hayley Williams too.

[Kisuke]

[QUOTE]=fabbriche;4114158]QUOTE]

fail you have no idea what your talking about beyonce has 3,5 octave vocal range
and beyonce can belt higher then christina as christina her textura ends at E5 while beyonce can effortless belt up to F5/F#5, while christina struggles to belt past D5.
not to mention beyonce her conected range is wider then christinas
and
mariah aint got no 7 octave vocal range
where would she get it from she would have to sing notes off the piano
mariah E2-F#7 5 octaves and 1,5 notes
also christina aint no ones soprano .
kelly clarkson and nicole scherzinger are soprano

[InsanoShano]

This. Thread. Is. A. JOKE!

Behind the holy trinity is only one..

[Shy Boy]

Alot of people find her voice annoying but she definitely deserves to be mentioned:

[Kisuke]

[Deuces]

Originally posted by kisuke

JUST WONDERFUL!!!!!!! Not too many pop stars can do that

[Green]

My list is based in their whole careers, no matter if they don't sing as great as they used to.

01. Whitney Houston
02. Mariah Carey
03. Celine Dion
04. Toni Braxton
05. Christina Aguilera
06. Beyoncé
07. P!nk
08. Kelly Clarkson
09. Leona Lewis
10. Alicia Keys

[Deuces]

Originally posted by fabbriche

Did they commend Beyonce's vocals or her performances and stage presence alone? 'Cause they are two different things. Sorry I don't follow Beyonce. But I know Whitney also commended Christina's vocals. And that is the biggest compliment a singer can get coming from 2 of the greatest divas. The only diva that did not commend Christina for is Mariah because they're not in good terms with each other.



When Mariah was Beyonce's age, she was magnificent vocally. And besides, only 4 pop stars are true sopranos - Mariah, Celine, Whitney and Christina. Mariah has 7-octave vocal range. The other 3 have 5 octaves. Beyonce has 3 octaves only. The above 4 could belt out high notes that Beyonce could never. No wonder why she doesn't have much ballad songs.

She has PLENTY of ballads...so check your facts before you start dishing out some delusional comments! And MiMi seems to love her and think she's a great singer...

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Deuces

JUST WONDERFUL!!!!!!! Not too many pop stars can do that

no one of her generation

[Deuces]

Originally posted by GreenRocks1

My list is based in their whole careers, no matter if they don't sing as great as they used to.

01. Whitney Houston
02. Mariah Carey
03. Celine Dion
04. Toni Braxton
05. Christina Aguilera
06. Beyoncé
07. P!nk
08. Kelly Clarkson
09. Leona Lewis
10. Alicia Keys

4,5,6 are interchangeable but I agree good list.

[Deuces]

Originally posted by kisuke

no one of her generation

The Queen

[Skeleton Boy]

Oh itsuky, it turns out Leona and Alan have sung together.

[Itsuky]

Originally posted by Skeleton Boy

Oh itsuky, it turns out Leona and Alan have sung together.

NO WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

alan is the one in the pink dress btw!

OMG I love this. Two of my favorite voices of all time singing together I'M NOT WORTHYYYYY.

[Lasers]

Originally posted by PopBoi

Beyonce had a whole disc dedicated to ballads in her last album, she has plenty

I actually think that in 20 -30 years Beyonce will still be able to belt out like she does now, I can't see her losing her voice for a LONG time.

I can see Bee losing her voice at 35.. She belts WAYY to much, and has the tendency to oversing sometimes..

[Lasers]

and alicia keys is vocally overrated.

[Skeleton Boy]

Originally posted by Itsuky

NO WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

alan is the one in the pink dress btw!

OMG I love this. Two of my favorite voices of all time singing together I'M NOT WORTHYYYYY.

That instrument she's playing is so cool. She seems very talented