[Harmonic Dreamer]

Oh, the delusions...

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by ♔Drais Ivy Carter

And Thanksgiving ratings.

But it's true, no?

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by funnychick

Gaga a better performer than Beyonce?



Not with those out of breath vocals while doing stale choreography.

When has The Queen been Out of breath ?
Edit:Sorry

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Originally posted by MrBeyonceFan

When has The Queen been Out of breath ?

They meant Gaga not Beyoncé. Gaga in my opinion has a nice voice and she can play piano. Take away the theatrics and costumes, and you have a subpar performer. Do the same to Bey and you'll still be captivated.

[iheartBrit]

Yes.

[DejaVu]

Tbh, Gaga and Beyonce represent a different generation of popstars.

Gaga is grouped with Katy, Rihanna & Ke$ha.

Beyonce is with Kelly, Christina, Britney & Pink.

Both are the "Performers of their generation".

[Drais.]

Originally posted by BTrisc

But it's true, no?

That higher Thanksgiving ratings make her a better performer? Of course not.

[Scuba_Dive]

Originally posted by DejaVu

Gaga is an entertainer. her performance skills are average. Without her props, army of gay dancers & lighting effects, it'd be no different then watching Rihanna perform.

Beyonce IS the entertainment. She can put on a show with nothing but her talent. That's a true performer.

...

[RazB32]

Bey been in the game 16 years w/ Destiny's Child and that's not even a full generation. Gaga is taking footsteps in hindsight.
Gaga is a better PERFORMER because of the theatrics, whereas I think Bey is the better ENTERTAINER due to the variety her shows have (medleys, ballards, classics and of course the dancing)

They are both besties and support each others concerts/music... and they run the female industry. That's all I'm here for.

[Scuba_Dive]

Originally posted by Walley

Beyonce doesn't need controversy to make a performance effective. GaGa has these crazy costumes and over-the-top sets, but still manages to get mixed to poor reviews on her live performances and live vocal ability.

I wanna see these reviews.

[J.Givenchy]

i like the both of them very much, but beyonce stays and gaga sits as far as the poll goes..anyone saying otherwise is clearly a stan of gaga or not a fan of beyonce and they can sit as well

[FreeXone]

Beyonce is still the better singer and dancer.

[jinzo]

Originally posted by RazB32

Bey been in the game 16 years w/ Destiny's Child and that's not even a full generation. Gaga is taking footsteps in hindsight.
Gaga is a better PERFORMER because of the theatrics, whereas I think Bey is the better ENTERTAINER due to the variety her shows have (medleys, ballards, classics and of course the dancing)

They are both besties and support each others concerts/music... and they run the female industry. That's all I'm here for.

Interesting point though, where could Gaga be after 16 years in the game?

[fineandbambi]

mmmmm I voted for Beyoncé by accident.

[Desnudate]

I never got the whole "dancing ability" thing. To me, learning choreography doesn't mean you can dance. It just means you know how to step in the right place at the right time. Dancing would be if you hear a song, and you can automatically ride the beat & rhythm with some Ciara-type back bends or some ****.

[Rafael]

Originally posted by DejaVu

Tbh, Gaga and Beyonce represent a different generation of popstars.

Gaga is grouped with Katy, Rihanna & Ke$ha.

Beyonce is with Kelly, Christina, Britney & Pink.

Both are the "Performers of their generation".

THIS!!!!!

[BSPEARSUK]

No one will ever beat Beyoncé, she is the full package & it helps that she's beautiful too!

[hamozfinest]

Originally posted by Desnudate

I never got the whole "dancing ability" thing. To me, learning choreography doesn't mean you can dance. It just means you know how to step in the right place at the right time. Dancing would be if you hear a song, and you can automatically ride the beat & rhythm with some Ciara-type back bends or some ****.

& that's exactly the point, some people can go attend as many dance classes as they want & still look as stiff as anything, in my opinion being able to move your body fluidly is not something that can be taught, u can either 'move' or u can't, & comparing Bey & Gaga is a prime example. No shade against Gaga though, I adore her live vocals, bey&gaga singing live>>>>>>the other girls

[Jameson Teqkilla]

I actually think they're on the same plane in terms of ability to put on a show.

I think when they're old and so are we we'll be paying thousands to go see their co-headlining Vegas residency show.

[Bandrew]

Not in a million years, Beyonce's performances can't be touched.