| |
Rate the American Idols: Season 5!
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
1. Elliot- By far. Wow. His best performance yet. Randy is crazy... I think he's confusing runs with pitchiness.
2. Katharine- She was off at some points, I admit, but she still was ravishing and shined at key moments. Like Simon said... she ALMOST had THE performance. I really hope she does eventually...
3. Taylor- Much better than last week. He is ridiculous though and I don't like him.
GAP
4. Paris- Pretty good, she sounded weird in some parts though.
5. Chris- Wow... those high notes... he pretty much screamed, and I usually don't like when people say someone "screamed a performance" cause its usually not true. But decent overall .
6. Ace- Really not that bad... I liked his runs at the end. His voice just doesn't fit the song, and he's bad overall.
7. Kellie- I can't believe they bought that. That stupid costume gimmick... sure she performed it, but her vocal performance was subpar.
8. Bucky- Poor Bucky. He needs to go.
Bottom 3: Bucky, Ace, Katharine/Chris (Chris is close to bottom 3 in dialidol rankings)
Bottom 2: Bucky, Ace
Going Home: Ace/Bucky (I really have no idea)
I think it's no brainer that either Ace or Bucky is going home. However, Chris and Katharine are both in danger of being bottom 3.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
^Ugh, that Top 2 prediction on Dialidol disgusts me.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Taste Like Fire
^Ugh, that Top 2 prediction on Dialidol disgusts me.
|
I agree. I don't like Kellie or Taylor one bit.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
8 Queens Going Down
Katharine (3/10) A ballad? That could be her dealth knell, since she was just boring. Like Chris, I see her being boring meaning she's hitting the B3. Vocal she missed some things, but was boring even when on. And no, she was not on on the first held note. And the other notes. And the midsection. And the pageant smile needs to die.
Elliot (1/10) A soft rock take on "Somebody To Love"? Considering he was inaudiable for half of it, it was just bad. Stop stretching notes unnecessary and try sticking to the notes on the page! (Kellie: A Page? What's that? I'm confused by the acksent!)
Bucky (1/10) "Fat Bottom Girls" is mah song, damn it! And gawd damn he sounded rougher than hell on this. Nowhere on key and the gravel in his pipes ruined the effect of the song.
Chris (0/10) Well, no one can say he tried to be Freddie, cuz not even he can pull of those notes. Instead, we get a Live retread. Dude, just because Pearl Jam has returned again doesn't mean alt stations will sign you. As for the actual signing, he found the goat in his throat and tried riding it for hours. And since tommorow is an hour, your ass is a shocking B3er.
Ace (0/10) NO! NOT WE WILL ROCK YOU! Wow, I forgot how possible it is to yell and be flat at the same time. Dropped words, wonky notes, assy falseto jump. As horrible as expected.
Paris (0/10) THE ---- IS U WEARING? And do we want her gone now? Cuz she's dressed like a conservative Pussycat Doll with a rather bad wig and some pitchy as hell vocals. By far her worst performance and a horrid way to end the show.
Kellie (0/10) OH MY HOLY HELL! I heard rumors of this all week and dreamed it would happen. Connie will be happy his version is now not the worst, cuz she was nowhere on key and looked vacant and lost. And the bitch cannot prowl or strut. The most hysterically funny performance ever!
Taylor (0/10) Did he die and no one tell him? Good Lord his voice is shot. And he just had to return to spazzing out. Looked half into the song, all over the place vocally and there was no reason to look like a dork. Be glad you have way too much fan support, cuz you should be leaving tonight.
Should Be B3: ALL. OF. THEM. But really Paris, Kellie, Taylor
Should Go Home: Taylor
Will Be B3: Chris, Ace, Kat
Gone: Ace
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
based on last night's performances....
08.Ace
07.Bucky
06.Elliot
05.Kellie
04.Paris
03.Taylor
02.Chris
01.Katherine
|
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Worst night ever
Paris: 8.5
Taylor: 6.5
Elliott: 6.0
Kellie: 5.0
Ace: 4.5
Bucky: 4.0
Chris: 4.0
Katharine: 3.5
Top 8:
1. Paris: 69.0 (=)
2. Kellie: 55.9 (=)
3. Ace: 52.3 (=)
4. Elliott: 52.2 (+1)
5. Chris: 51.1 (-1)
6. Katharine: 45.0 (=)
7. Taylor: 44.7 (=)
8. Bucky: 37.6 (=)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
A Better Night
01. Katharine - 9.5/10
02. Paris - 9/10
03. Elliott - 7/10
04. Kellie - 6/10
05. Bucky - 5.5/10
06. Chris - 5/10
07. Taylor - 4/10
08. Ace - 4/10
|
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
1) Katharine (=)
2) Chris (=)
3) Elliott (+1)
4) Paris (-1)
5) Taylor (=)
6) Kellie (=)
7) Ace (+1) :vomit:
8) Mandisa (+1)
9) Lisa (+1)
10) Melissa (+1)
11) Bucky (-4)
12) Kevin (=)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
1) Katharine
2) Paris
---
3) Elliot
4) Chris
5) Ace
---
6) Kellie
7) Taylor
---
8) Mandisa
9) Melissa
10) Lisa
11) Kinnik
12) Will
13) Becky
14) Stevie
15) Brenna
16) Gedeon
17) Bucky ^_^
18) Sway
19) Patrick
20) Ayla
21) Kevin
22) Heather
23) David
24) Bobby
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Paris
02. Katharine
03. Elliot
04. Chris
05. Kellie
06. Ace
07. Taylor
08. Melissa
09. Mandisa
10. Lisa
11. Becky
12. Kinnik
13. Ayla
14. Heather
15. Stevie
16. Bucky
17. Brenna
18. Will
19. Gedeon
20. Sway
21. Patrick
22. David
23. Bobby
24. Kevin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
01. taylor................(+7) it was the most non-queen performance but i did enjoy it
02. katharine............(-1) enjoyed it a lot, a few off keys but its all good
03. elliot..................(+2) pretty good, 1 problem though he over sings a lot and too much runs
04. kellie..................(-1) it was so much better than expected but not her best
05. chris...................(-3) it was ok for me, if only he picked a better song wouldve been his moment
06. paris..................(+1) ok, nothing specially really. bad week for her once again
07. bucky..................(+2) a lot better than ace, but ofcourse i didnt enjoy it
08. ace.....................(-4) wow this sucked so bad, his stares annoy me so much
Top 9
01. katharine ............(+2) what can i say, great great great!
02. chris .................(+3) to me it was good, not great but better than the rest
03. kellie .................(+3) it was pretty enjoyable, still think she needs to lose the make up
04. ace ....................(+5) thought song fit his voice good, but he still sounds whiney to me
05. elliot ..................(+2) good nothing special
06. mandisa ...............(-4) it wasnt bad, just didnt enjoy it much
07. paris ...................(-6) it sounded way too much like karaoke to me
08. taylor ..................(-4) wow that was boring, didnt suck though
09. bucky ...................(+1) wow he ruined that song bad
Top 10
01. paris ........................ (+4) enjoyed the performance and theres no denying she can dance but it looked out of place
02. mandisa .................... (=) great performance but it sounded like she was yelling at some parts
03. katharine .................. (-2) intro worried me a lot but i did like the rest of the song, couldve done better though
04. taylor ....................... (+4) wasnt the best performance but a lot better than rest, this theme just sucks
05. chris ........................ (-1) it was okay, kinda yelled too much though
06. kellie ....................... (=) ok vocals, very boring and fire your make up stylist!
07. elliot ........................ (+2) wow what the hell was that, poser anyone? lol but yeah the best out of the sucky performance
08. lisa ......................... (-1) what happened? i dont know where the lisa i liked went
09. ace .......................... (-6) there he goes again, the whiny voice! gaahhhhh
10. bucky ........................ (=) just dont like you, please go now!
TOP 11
01. katharine ............... (=) as usual loved the performance. her voice is just amazing
02. mandisa ................. (+1) just as consistent as katharine
03. ace ........................ (+8) wow, totally made up for like everything. his past performances just sucked ass
04. chris ....................... (+2) great performance as usual, good job with the arrangement
05. paris ....................... (-1) it was very good, went down my ranking but doesnt mean it was worse than last week
06. kellie ....................... (+2) vocals getting a lot better, keep it up
07. lisa .......................... (-2) she did pretty good but got overshadowed by paris and mandisa. hope shes not bottom 3 again!
08. taylor ........................ (-6) went down in ranking a lot but he didnt do bad. he did pretty good but everyone was just really good this week
09. elliot ......................... (=) he did good but just dont like him that much. i dunno, he just hasnt impressed me
10. bucky ........................ (=) as much as his singing is far from my cup of tea, he's less annoying than harry potters and chicken littles love child
11. kevin ......................... (+1) go the fkkk away already. his nostrils and lisp is so annoying when he sings. his gf is so much better. god its so annoying seeing loser kids that are cocky!!! lolz
TOP 12
01. katharine ............ she has to win, no exception!
02. taylor .................. wow i was never a fan, but he impressed me a lot
03. mandisa .............. always great, very consistent
04. paris ................... fun performance, good vocals
05. lisa ..................... good performance, but she really needs a song to shine soon
06. chris ................... my favorite guy, but it was an ok performance
07. melissa ............... wow i was actually surprise, she made it her own, good job
08. kellie ................... was very disappointed, that wasnt the kellie i like
09. elliot ................... was never really a fan, he was ok
10. bucky .................. it was his personal best i think but his best is not good enough
11. ace ..................... he is just starting to go down faster than a rock in my bock
12. kevin ................... to me he is just a loser who thinks he's all that now, go home!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
Overall Statistic
points | idol
57 katharine
43 chris
42 taylor
42 paris
39 mandisa
38 kellie
32 elliot
30 ace
19 lisa
19 bucky
06 melissa
03 kevin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Chris - 10/10
02. Paris - 9.5/10
03. Katharine - 9/10 (Diana Did It Better)
04. Elliot - 8.5/10
05. Ace - 8/10
06. Taylor - 7/10
07. Kellie - 4/10
Should Go - Kelly (Kelly, Taylor, Ace Bottom)
Will Go - Ace Or Elliot (Paris or Taylor will be with them)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
what a boring night. 
1. Chris (he's on top because everyone else was boring)
2. Taylor (that was okay but it was boring)
3. Paris (read #2)
4. Elliott (Meh)
5. Ace (read #4)
6. Katharine (sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo boring)
7. Kellie (god damnit, she's just asking to get voted out! "I won't put you through the torture. Seriously, that was a very deserving performance to get her packing. If it was anyone else, you would say 'bye-bye' (except Taylor, Chris), but NOT Kellie  )
Should Be:
Bottom 3- Katharine, Kellie, Ace
Going Home- Kellie
Will Be:
Bottom 3- Elliott, Kellie, Ace
Going Home- Elliott
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
I actually thought tonight was really good aside from those 2 that I really hate.
Chris: 7.5
Paris: 9.5
Taylor: 4.0
Elliot: 7.5
Kellie: 0.5
Ace: 6.5
Katharine: 10.0
Tonight:
1) Katharine
2) Paris
3) Chris
4) Elliot
5) Ace
6) Taylor
700) Kellie
Should be bottom 3: Taylor, Kellie, Ace
Should Go Home: Taylor (Just because I hate him that much more)
Bottom 3: Elliot, Ace, Kellie
Going Home: Could be any of them ,especially after Kellie's performance tonight
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
It was a good night imo
01.Katharine (10)
02.Paris (9.5)
03.Chris (9)
04.Taylor (8)
05.Ace (7.5)
06.Elliot (7)
07.Kellie (5)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
1. Katharine
2. Chris
3. Elliott
4. Paris
5. Taylor
6. Kellie
7. Ace
Will be bottom 3 : Kellie, Ace, and Elliott
Will go: Ace
Should be bottom 3 : Kellie, Ace, and Taylor
Should go: Ace
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
There were some really great performances tonight, and only one REALLY bad performance.
1. Katharine- Simon got it right... she was beyond amazing. The best peformance this season.
2. Taylor- I hate to admit that I liked the performance, but I did... I love how it built toward the end.
3. Chris- One of his best... I also liked the change.
4. Elliot- Also great, it was safe and kinda boring, but I don't think he'll be going home this week.
5. Paris- She's very skilled and has great control, but she sounded kind of affected.
6. Ace- Not bad. Much better than most of his performances.
7. Kellie- Wow. She REALLY blew it this week. Too bad she's getting pity votes.
Bottom 3 (based partly on dialidol): Kellie, Paris, Ace
Going Home: No doubt Ace... he's way at the bottom on dialidol.
DialIdol
Rank Idol DialIdol Score Margin Of Error Actual Rank
1-2 Taylor Hicks 50.387 1.765 -
1-2 Elliott Yamin 48.274 1.802 -
3-4 Kellie Pickler 45.491 1.85 -
3-4 Katharine McPhee 43.849 1.878 -
5-6 Chris Daughtry 42.557 1.899 -
5-6 Paris Bennett 39.774 1.945 -
7 Ace Young 32.84 2.054
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 6/9/2002
Posts: 6,789
|
1.Paris
2.Chris
3.Taylor
4.Katharine
5.Elliot
6.Ace
*gap*
7.Kellie
should go home:Kellie
will go home: hopefully Kellie, but that looks doubtful now. so probably Ace or Elliot.
|
|
|
|
|
|
