[Torturo]

Originally posted by Mariano

SLANT gave it a 60 ?

That's why those "critics" don't have any credibility.

The Fame 50
The Fame Monster 70
Born This Way 80
ARTPOP 70 (he said Joanne is better than it so idk how that makes sense)
Cheek To Cheek 40
Joanne 60

Dangerous Woman 70
Lemonade 70
25 60
ANTI 50

[Whore of Babylon]

slant is on crack

[Haus]

Can someone plz politely drag them in the comments for rating it less than ARTPOP I aint making a Disqus account

[GetYourAssInMyBed]

Slant are a joke.

[DivaCup]

Originally posted by Haus

Can someone plz politely drag them in the comments for rating it less than ARTPOP I aint making a Disqus account

type up a comment and i'll post it for you.

[charot]

"Name over quality"

[HausOfGerard]

I never expected A-YO to go off like this

[TinkerbellClap]

Can someone point out how they think it's better than ARTPOP but it's rated lower than it? lol

[Whore of Babylon]

to slant dic is a reggae song and ctm is a christmas jingle. ogh detected. no respectable music critic can be this stupid.

[L.B GAGA]

Ignore the haters. If you expect the critics to litsen to the music, then your greatly mistaken. Enjoy the music, ignore the haters. If they drageed Artpop i would have been cool but this HELL NO its the hate bandwagon mess.
A-YO

[DoubleDutchess]

Originally posted by GetYourAssInMyBed

Slant are a joke.

[Phoenixstar]

I got the response from him. Let me post it in next post.

[Haus]

Originally posted by Saskia

type up a comment and i'll post it for you.

"In the last paragraph, you essentially state that Joanne is a better album than ARTPOP, yet you gave Joanne 3 stars vs. ARTPOP's 3.5 stars. Why?"

Feel free to make any modifications hihi

[Phoenixstar]

"Hi there, I disagree that the review isn't saying that Joanne is better than Artpop. I do say that it's more consistent and focused than Artpop, but think what works on that album plays better to Lady Gaga's strengths. Hope that helps clarify!

Thanks!"

What should I response? Like this is kinda mess. More consistent and focused yet not better than ARTPOP?

Edit: oh this is what I wrote to them since I was really curious.

"Hello,

While your review on Lady Gaga - Joanne was very fascinating to read. What I'm getting, from the way you write and comparison, is that you are saying that it's better than ARTPOP which I agree about this. But what confused me about this is that you gave JOANNE a 3/5 while ARTPOP 3.5/5 which clearly means that ARTPOP is better JOANNE, no?
I'm hoping to know if you made a mistake with score, possibly please fix it or state about it.

Thank you. Have a nice day."

[DoubleDutchess]

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Phoenixstar

"Hi there, I disagree that the review isn't saying that Joanne is better than Artpop. I do say that it's more consistent and focused than Artpop, but think what works on that album plays better to Lady Gaga's strengths. Hope that helps clarify!

Thanks!"

What should I response? Like this is kinda mess. More consistent and focused yet not better than ARTPOP?

tell him artpop is trash and that he should raise score to 4

[DivaCup]

Originally posted by Haus

"In the last paragraph, you essentially state that Joanne is a better album than ARTPOP, yet you gave Joanne 3 stars vs. ARTPOP's 3.5 stars. Why?"

Feel free to make any modifications hihi

"Hold on, this is waiting to be approved by Slant Magazine."

[reloaded]

OMG HER DRAGGING the chain smokers on Twitter!!

[Phoenixstar]

Originally posted by Torturo

tell him artpop is trash and that he should raise score to 4

Sis, no, I need to response clean and brief.

[UFO]

Wait I'm actually warming up to Hey Girl now, still a bit lacklustre tho.

I legit like every track ! btw I'm so glad Gaga didn't try to imitate Florence aklfjakf THAT would've been a mess