Ew Caleb needs to stay gone.
Also I am sick of Paige, and I have been sick of her for forever. I wish they just wouldn't have killed Maya cause I want Paige dead.
Noel, Melissa, and Wren need to come back. The show would feel so much more complete if their characters were around and involved. Same with Cece. I hate how often they introduce new people. Lol, and where the hell is Jenna. This show is so all over the place that I constantly forget what happens to people.
He was interesting at first as that bad boy for Hannah, and I enjoyed their relationship but lord, he ended up being so irritating the last couple of seasons. All he would do is try to baby sit Hannah and chime in every few seconds. His character is useless to the show now.
I agree there is some similarities between the book and the show but it's not an exact copy which is what I like, but the writers have said numerous times now that they're not doing the twin route.
All the cops in the town are corrupt though so I don't really trust anything they say, and I thought they identified her body based off the clothing she was wearing that night and not dental records (correct me if I'm wrong can't remember exactly).
The whole show is full of plot holes and red herrings so nothing really surprises me anymore, the writers lie all the time with what they say but if they do go down the twin route it would just be a cop out.
If anyone is interested the cast will be on GMA on Tuesday to talk about the show, give hints, ect.