Haley is in danger this week, even if she got the only standing ovation of the night. I have a feeling James is going home, but I really hope this is not the end for her
.....Scotty is country amazing and Lauren is the next Kelly Clarkson. Even if they don't win they will smash the charts AND YOU WILL DEAL WITH IT. That lessor Hayley will end up like Taylor Hicks or and that dude who won last year....
Only four remaining. It's officially crunch time on American Idol.
Tensions were running high on the Idol stage when Haley Reinhart shot back at judge Randy Jackson over a critique she didn't care for. Tempers flared, Ryan Seacrest had to step in, but what happened when the show cut to commercial?
We saw it all from our seat behind the judges' table and caught up with Haley post-show to hear her side of the story....
Not every performance on Idol is going to get good reviews from the judges, but week after week we've seen Haley get the brunt of their bad news. Wednesday was no different when Randy laid into her cover of Michael Jackson's "Earth Song." It was clear Haley wasn't happy about the feedback, and after the cameras stopped rolling she basically stalked off stage only raising her hand once to the audience. Ryan and producer Nigel Lythgoe swarmed Randy, who kind of laughed, threw up his hands and said, "What am I supposed to do?"
Although she killed it on her second song, when we chatted with Haley after the show she was still fuming over the disagreement.
Regardless of what the judges think, Haley isn't backing down and just taking the advice for what it is as she moves forward.
Haley wasn't the only one bothered by the judges' response. Lauren Alaina was on hand to put a reassuring arm around Haley's shoulders during commercial breaks. After the show, she revealed to us how she felt about the judges' feedback and how she sees Haley's standing in the competition.
Only four remaining. It's officially crunch time on American Idol.
Tensions were running high on the Idol stage when Haley Reinhart shot back at judge Randy Jackson over a critique she didn't care for. Tempers flared, Ryan Seacrest had to step in, but what happened when the show cut to commercial?
We saw it all from our seat behind the judges' table and caught up with Haley post-show to hear her side of the story....
Not every performance on Idol is going to get good reviews from the judges, but week after week we've seen Haley get the brunt of their bad news. Wednesday was no different when Randy laid into her cover of Michael Jackson's "Earth Song." It was clear Haley wasn't happy about the feedback, and after the cameras stopped rolling she basically stalked off stage only raising her hand once to the audience. Ryan and producer Nigel Lythgoe swarmed Randy, who kind of laughed, threw up his hands and said, "What am I supposed to do?"
Although she killed it on her second song, when we chatted with Haley after the show she was still fuming over the disagreement.
Regardless of what the judges think, Haley isn't backing down and just taking the advice for what it is as she moves forward.
Haley wasn't the only one bothered by the judges' response. Lauren Alaina was on hand to put a reassuring arm around Haley's shoulders during commercial breaks. After the show, she revealed to us how she felt about the judges' feedback and how she sees Haley's standing in the competition.
I kind of hope that Haley goes home this week, because next week the judges pick a song for the top 3, right? And I just know that if J.Lo or Randy pick a song for Haley to sing, they are going to pick the most awful song for her to do. If she doesn't win the whole thing, this would be the perfect note for her to go out on: first her standing up for herself against the judges (shows she believes in her talents and her art) and then she gets a standing O her last time out.
If James wins then it means that the only reason Adam Lambert didnt win is because he is GAY. there i said it.
Well, Don't forget James looks really good.
It maight have something to do with this.
I want James to win because I enjoy watching him, but he wasn't that good tonigt,
The attitude of Randy and Jennifer against Haley was disgusting.
Earth Song was ok, not awesome, but she's is the only one getting critiques when everyone else sucked really hard on at least one performance and they get praised!
It's really ridiculous. There's even a clip of Randy saying that he's not rooting for her.
Well, Don't forget James looks really good.
It maight have something to do with this.
I want James to win because I enjoy watching him, but he wasn't that good tonigt,
okay gurl hes not THAT good looking. anyway haley is the cutest one left
The attitude of Randy and Jennifer against Haley was disgusting.
Earth Song was ok, not awesome, but she's is the only one getting critiques when everyone else sucked really hard on at least one performance and they get praised!
It's really ridiculous. There's even a clip of Randy saying that he's not rooting for her.
You left out the bit of them giving her the only standing O of the night.
Are does that bit not sit well with your conspiracy theory?
Dude, she had the right to respond to the stupidity that J.Lo and Randy spewed in regards to her first performance. Their main critique was that the song wasn't popular and that it didn't make people stand up jumping up and down.....ARE THEY ****ING ME?!
The theme was for songs that inspired them. Did they actually expect Haley to do some Dance/Club song?!
It's complete idiocy. **** Randy and J.Lo....
Ugh.
adam tweeted twice about haley!! and shes a trending topic on Twitter!!
@ Adam Lambert
Bottom line- in my opinion, Haley would make the edgiest, most original album out of the three. #Realness
@Adam Lambert
Haley gets criticized cuz she's the best and SO not cookie cutter. She was Fiesty 2n b/c she's a strong, smart woman. my fav kind o woman.
I'm late but I just want to say that I hate these judges. They keep criticizing Haley - only Haley - when clearly she is the best one on the remaining hopefuls. They always try to find a reason to criticize her, and tonight they ended up criticizing her song choice. I like how Haley reacted. It gives her the edge. I was clapping all the time when she shot back 'cause she was in point.
